Pick 1 of these top prospects/young players

[member 147413]

Matthews

 

[Critical13]

I would probably choose Dahlin, but you can't just give all credit to MacKinnon of what Rantanen is doing currently.

This is just what happens when two elite players find chemistry.

Oh I am not giving Mac credit, just a question.

Dahlin, Eichel, Barzal make more sense to me but there is no ignoring Rants #s.

 

[CP4]

No votes for Barzy, Laine or Pastrnak but Pettersson has 4 is very intriguing to me!

Did you make this thread to make subtle jabs at Pettersson or just to pump your Leafs player tires?

 

[Critical13]

Did you make this thread to make subtle jabs at Pettersson or just to pump your Leafs player tires?

That's exactly why I mentioned 3 non Leafs

 

[PeterForsberg]

If you're going to put Matthews, at least put Mack too...

 

[Critical13]

If you're going to put Matthews, at least put Mack too...

Mac is 3 years older

 

[PeterForsberg]

Mac is 3 years older

He's 23 while Eichel is 22 lmao. I'll take it that Mack will destroy this thread because you knew Matthews would win.

 

[Critical13]

He's 23 while Eichel is 22 lmao. I'll take it that Mack will destroy this thread because you knew Matthews would win.

Make the same thread with Mac in it then? lol I dont care, I just rattled off the high end guys from the last few drafts.

 

[God King Fudge]

Give me one of the d men. Probably Heiskanen.

 

[PeterForsberg]

Make the same thread with Mac in it then? lol I dont care, I just rattled off the high end guys from the last few drafts.

Nate MacKinnon or Auston Matthews for the next decade?

we saw what happens there

 

[Critical13]

Nate MacKinnon or Auston Matthews for the next decade?

we saw what happens there

Congrats on being a fan of a good player

 

[Breakers]

LOL

This thread screams "acknowledge me" to the leafs fan base with putting Matthews in and not McDavid.

 

[PeterForsberg]

Congrats on being a fan of a good player

Congrats on trying to show the world that Matthews is the best young player compared to the players you specially decided to remove such as Mack and McDavid! Btw McDavid is 21 where is he?

 

[Critical13]

Congrats on trying to show the world that Matthews is the best young player compared to the players you specially decided to remove such as Mack and McDavid! Btw McDavid is 21 where is he?

That narrative is in your head my friend. Matthews has lost polls to almost everyone listed.

McDavid is the clear #1.

Matthews has less than 50% btw, it's closer than you think

 

[PeterForsberg]

That narrative is in your head my friend. Matthews has lost polls to almost everyone listed.

McDavid is the clear #1.

Matthews has less than 50% btw, it's closer than you think

If you follow hockey, you know who wins this poll.

 

[Mountlaine]

It's Dahlin or Matthews. Matthews has had some injuries so I'm gonna play it safe with Dahlin.

 

[CP4]

That's exactly why I mentioned 3 non Leafs

>Makes thread stating "just simply pick a player you'd take"
>People pick Pettersson
>"Huh sure is weird people are picking this player very intriguing"

You shouldn't have even added Pettersson if you were going to be so estranged when people chose him, too bad he has the third highest results so far.

 

[IceNeophyte]

No votes for Barzy, Laine or Pastrnak but Pettersson has 4 is very intriguing to me!

The newest toy gets played with.

 

[Critical13]

>Makes thread stating "just simply pick a player you'd take"
>People pick Pettersson
>"Huh sure is weird people are picking this player very intriguing"

You shouldn't have even added Pettersson if you were going to be so estranged when people chose him, too bad he has the third highest results so far.

Im sorry I hurt your feelings with my comment

 

[CP4]

Im sorry I hurt your feelings with my comment

My feelings aren't hurt, just try not to make your obvious bias so present when you make a poll like this, most people have already called you out for it.

 

[M2Beezy]

Dahlin and Rantanen in a league of their own here. Mackinnon would be with them if he was in the poll

Then a big group after that

 

[Ben White]

Dahlin and Rantanen in a league of their own here. Mackinnon would be with them if he was in the poll

Then a big group after that

Pettersson > Dahlin

 

[M2Beezy]

Pettersson > Dahlin

Right now yes, but i feel Dahlin has the edge for my future projection. Close, and i could change it, but thats my feeling now after a quarter the season and Dahlin starting to put it together already

 

[Derg12]

I'm biased towards #1 D men regardless of whether Dahlin is on the Sabres or not but I'll admit it factors in.

 

[WetcoastOrca]

My feelings aren't hurt, just try not to make your obvious bias so present when you make a poll like this, most people have already called you out for it.

His agenda is pretty apparent.
It’s a shame that a few of the people who start polls can’t try to be more objective.