These statements aren't mutually exclusive, K. It is possible for gigantic mistakes like Jobing.com arena to be both well-intentioned and hilariously poorly conceived. Sure, it's not exclusive to America. But in the context of the business of hockey in 2012, it's pretty out front.
Sure, true enough. Theres no question a lot of these developments are ego driven by politicians (Drapeau for eg.) & franchise owners, developers and promoters in building monuments to themselves. When the economies flush & optimism reigns, most people are too busy to pay attention or get swept up in the enthusiasm. Certainly that was the case in Montreal on the heels of the hugely successful Expo 67 in running full speed at the 76 Olympics.
When the economy tanks, as was the case in Phoenix followed by Moyes' BK & Balsillies hostile relocation attempt everythings questioned & dissected. Formerly intelligent & reasoned decisions seeming in hindsight pretty much nutz. The damage caused to Phoenix by the lockout in 04 when the building was about to open was serious, losing their momentum. Then the sub-prime housing crash, Ellman running out of money & credit, Moyes, Gretzky and his former Agent in over their heads with everyone apparently getting paid 2-3-8X's what their peers elsewhere were receiving, on & on we go.
Montreal got stuck with the Big 'O' , promises made by then Mayor Drapeau that it'd all be paid off in jig time with the Expos', Pink Floyd Concerts, the French Air Force Ski Shows & the like. Didnt work out that way. Not only did Montreal lose its MLB franchise, the city only recently retired its crushing debt on the stadium & to make matters worse, lost the Expos', while its bridges collapsed, major arterys & roadways requiring a 4 wheeler to negotiate. Who knew in the 70's that building the Summer Games infrastructure & Olympic Stadium would create a bill that mortgaged the cities future detrimentally?. Optimism reigned supreme. Montreal Canadas' jewel city.
I really dont think Glendale Arena / Westgate was an ill conceived project, very very badly executed, but the vision?. That was good, clear. I have a great deal of sympathy for Glendale, despite its foibles, and I really do think it behooves the NHL to step up to the plate here & facilitate a sale, drop the price, get er' done...