It is absolutely insane to me that people think that Justin Schultz can replace Kris Letang in any position.
Letang literally just led a defense core of nobodies to a Stanley Cup Championship.
Hardly. Trevor Daley was awesome. Brian Dumoulin turned into a stud. Guys like Lovejoy, Cole, and Schultz raised their games tremendously. Even Maatta who just isn't well looked fine after getting some rest. Schultz is a vastly better PPQB and it's not even close. Daley is a better PPQB.
Kris Letang is the greatest 5 on 5 defenseman in the NHL, but a team cannot win a Cup if they don't have 6 guys who are playing well.
That's because he was severely sheltered. Letang was literally jumping on the ice to get him off the ice in the Sharks series.
I think you let Schultz play a full season and throw him anything about 15 minutes and you'll start seeing what kind of player he is. Even when Nisky was bad in Dallas, he wasn't a complete defensive liability. He just lost all his offensive swagger.
Pouliot is a far better defensive player than Justin Schultz will ever be for us. Hopefully we can build up Schultz enough that Las Vegas wants to take him though.
I never said anything about Schultz taking over for Letang and ES. Letang will get his 25 mins a game. My contention would be it would be much more beneficial for the team to limit the mins Kris gets on the PP and give them to Schultz who is a head and shoulder better PPQB, and then give those extra mins to Letang at ES where he is most beneficial to us. The PP has sucked now under multiple coaching regimes, and it's time to start looking at the guys who are running it. No one touches the puck more than Letang on that PP aside from maybe Malkin. It's clear as day that Letang is the problem to me as he has absolutely no feel for the offensive zone and how to work a powerplay to get Pkers to move around and work guys open. Watch a guy like Gonchar, Zubov, Pronger, Lidstrom, or other greats. They were able to work guys open with the things they did. Letang backs himself into a corner with no where to go, and then throws a hot potato pass to a guy 5 feet away and the puck is cleared. It's like clockwork.
Absolutely no one is saying Schultz should start playing 28 mins a game and supplanting Letang. I don't think people are at all far fetched in saying that if you take Letang off that top unit PP that the PP would be better. I actually think it's very true and has merit.
And if you do go back and read those threads in when that Dallas trade was made, they absolutely despised Niskanen and his defensive play. They all spoke about how he could skate and pass the puck. Defensively he was a liability. Pouliot may be better than Justin Schultz in the future, but he isn't now. That fact can be seen in the playoffs when Pouliot was sitting and Schultz was playing.