My initial reaction was to gulp a bit, but I'm coming around to the "fair for both sides" stance. My worry is, as others have brought up, that he'll never hit 50 points again. If you subtract his "December to Remember" where he produced at a 33-goal, 98-point and +88 pace over 15 games, the rest of his season he was at an 8-goal, 43-point and +14 pace over 63 games. Of course everyone looks markedly worse when you take away their best month of the season and he certainly produced in the playoffs, even after a significant injury to boot. Lastly, we also kind of owed him the benefit of the doubt as he way, way over-produced on last season's well-below-market-value contract.