Or, when everyone is healthy:
McGinn - Duchene - MacKinnon
Landeskog - O'Reilly - Parenteau
Talbot - Stastny - Tanguay
McLeod - Mitchell - Bordeleau
McGinn would add that grittiness that has been missing from Dutchy's line since Downie left and a good shot. MacKinnon and McGinn have already shown good chemistry in the limited time they've been together and both would be able to skate with Dutchy.
O'Reilly line could generate just as much offense, generally P.A. being pass first, Landy being shoot first, and ROR mixing it up
Stastny line would be great defensively IMO Tanguay has a very underrated defensive game and those two had great chemistry before Tanguay went down. Add Talbot to Stastny's play along the boards and that could be a great cycling line down low.
The 4th line would be the 4th line, they've played well so far with Cliche in there and would be better with Mitchell taking draws and playing where he belongs
let me know what you think
Not a fan to be honest.
This season is all about development.
Your lines essentially mean that we will have to trade atleast one of ROR or Stastny in order to make room for Mac down the middle in the near future. (probably both).
We were playing great at the beginning because we had essentially 3 offensively potent scoring lines.
After losing both Tanguay and Downie along with moving up Mac and PAP, we completely lost that edge. It is way easier to shut us down now.
Add that the defense and goaltending finally have come down to earth and one can see why we are losing.
With your lines we would waste Stastny again. Tanguay will be out for a while and Talbot is the kind of guy Stastny had to play with for the last few seasons (glorified 4th liner) and not exactly excelled. Stastny needs teammates who can belong into a top 6 to play with.
Talbot certainly is not that.
Keep ROR as a winger please.