There are concerns about Tippett's game, no doubt about it, however, nobody will deny what he is good at -taking the puck from anywhere on the ice, bringing it into the offensive zone with elite speed and ripping off an elite shot and scoring a goal. That can change games and I'm not sure why anybody would be upset about adding that dynamic to the team. Something we have sorely lacked.
He could probably do those things this season in the NHL now, though I'd like to see him work on the other areas and improve in decision-making and helping him be a better all around player.
Give him NHL coaching for 9 games then send him back to the OHL to dominate and work on the other parts of his game. Hope they don't rush but with our need at wing and the skills he does have, I can see him being in our lineup right away and being a productive (he will match Smith's totals at the least) player.
Watch the shift by shift of him in a playoff game, the skill is obvious:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-ddSb4anWo