There's many many ways to improve a team and WITHOUT giving a "top prospect", but it requires TWO things :
- the ability to SPEND the money necessary
- players that want to play in Ottawa AND for Melnyk
There's been a lot of players signed on the UFA market that could improve a team or at least provide a good stop gap. Exactly like we did with Dadonov. It didn't work out? Who cares? We got out of it and even got a 3rd round pick and a decent and cheap 3rd pairing D-man in return. Vegas seem to think that Dadonov will help them so they were ready to take that "financial risk". That's what NHL teams do. It's not that we don't do it, it's that we barely do it and when we do, it rarely works out (could list a lot of examples but will keep it "recent" with Dadonov, Murray, Stepan, Gudbranson...)
So why exactly are these moves not working out? Well, maybe we should ask the GM. Of course, if we'd have a better success rate, then we wouldn't need to always look to make more moves. Look at Bergevin last offseason : brought in Jake Allen, Joel Edmunson, Tyler Toffoli, Corey Perry and Josh Anderson. All moves that worked brilliantly. Let me know when Pierre Dorion hits anywhere close to 5/5 lol
Also, I have this impression that we now care more about the team's bottom line than anything else. Talked about it recently but look at Buffalo for example, how much they sucked the last 14 years, how much their owner is ready to lose every year while spending to the cap (until very recently). Sure, Melnyk is "not as rich" but that's the point.
If we didn't feel so bad and cared so much about Melnyk's finances (poor guy, we don't want him to lose a dollar!), we would ask for more without any shame. If he considers him not rich enough to operate a NHL team that will most likely have a negative operative income most years, then theres a line of people waiting to take the burden off his hands.
All that being said, here's a list of examples that could have improved the team without costing any asset or not that much :
Phillip Danault
Tomas Tatar
Brandon Saad
Jake McCabe
Pius Suter
Dougie Hamilton
David Savard
Mikael Granlund
Jaden Schwartz
Alexander Wennberg
Adam Larsson
Sam Reinhart
Pavel Buchnevich
Jared McCann
Viktor Arvidsson
Nick Leddy
Duncan Keith
Jake Bean
Jakub Voracek
Nate Schmidt