But Peressini went 2-2 against Barrie and gave up nine goals in the two wins over Barrie. Started three of four against North Bay but was pulled in one giving up 4 goals on 19 shots (which was also the last time Kingston played North Bay). His two wins came early in the season when North Bay was struggling and I was at one of those two games, he was awful and got bailed out by a strong team effort.
Peressini was the unquestioned starter at the start of the season and was given a significant amount of rope despite poor efforts. Did he win games.. yes. But look at the team playing in front of him his numbers should be what they were if not better. Peressini's play has tailed off more an more as the season went on while Helvig's has got better.
Helvig beat London twice.. there pretty good, 2-0 vs arguably the best team in the league. Beat Niagara three times, 2-0 vs North Bay, 3-0 vs Oshawa, 2-0 vs Ottawa, 1-0 vs Owen Sound that's 13-0 vs playoff teams. He's showed his ability to play well against good teams. Yeah he picked up victories against Hamilton, Guelph, Sudbury and Flint but its not his choice who he starts against, he simply went out and won and put up good numbers in the process.
Bottom line Helvig has been the better goalie all season regardless of opponent. Peressini has won games he shouldn't have won against good teams because of Kingston's talent, while Helvig has stole games against playoff caliber teams. Helvig is hot, Peressini is cold. Helvig proved himself in games against opponents of quality while Peressini was average to bad on some nights.
Peressini has been great throughout his career, but he just hasn't been great this year and with Helvig hot, having proved his capability to win against good teams it was the right call by Paul McFarland. Im a big fan of Lucas Peressini, he's battled for everything he's got, I was stoked he got a rookie camp offer from the Leafs but he hasn't been good. Sometimes we let past accomplishments cloud our judgement of players.