glenngineer
Registered User
It's not that Jokinen is a bad signing, or that I don't expect him to score 18-22 goals, it's just that this can't be considered "the fix." At the draft, Poile was bullish in his "we need a top center." In the days following, he toned it down to "we would like a top center, but if we can't get one, we like our youth," then signing Jokinen and saying "We see him on the wing, but who knows, maybe he's a center."
It reminds me a bit of when Ryan Suter left and a very green Roman Josi was a question mark. Initially the plan was "We have a plan B, we need a top 4 defenseman until Roman is ready," and then, without a game being played, "Roman is ready to play with Shea."
In hindsight, that worked out eventually...but not before the worst season the team has experienced in over 10 years.
I don't know if the solution is a trade for VL, a stop-gap signing of Derek Roy\Mike Ribeiro...or something else...but I think we're not taking advantage of an asset like James Neal with one of Colin Wilson\Jarnkrok\Fisher\Jokinen as the number one center.
The big knock on Wilson is he doesn't produce. I can't tell you how many times over the last few years he makes a pass that great players make only to find our guy burying the puck right into the goalies chest. If Wilson has a guy that can finish, his production will go up. Is he a Malkin or Crosby, no but who else in this league is? No one. If Neal gets the puck in his wheelhouse he will bury it. Wilson is a guy who can get it there. They also have size in their favor and it sure looks like Wilson has the willingness to bang out there since he made the switch to center.
Jarnkrok will be fine if he's with Smith. They had chemistry in the games that Jarnkrok was here and I suspect that will get better in time. Sometimes you don't have to have the best players on the ice but the ones that work well together with one another. I think this is one of those cases.
I'd rather have Wilson and Jarnkrok as my top 2 centers than any of the guys you listed above. VLC might be a fit but I don't see him as a long term answer. Roy is done. Ribiero is a head case. Let Lavi do his thing with the young talent and if it's not working out, address the situation. I think the pieces are there, I just think they need a tune up and fresh start in some cases.