Hey, no need to call me clueless.
I know I had the monster on my team and he wasn't that good. Didn't seem that good on the wings either.
Surprised oil fans are all in on talbot being a #1 though.
Apology on behalf of other fans rudeness.
Talbot is a #1, and was exceptional last year behind a very bad team. The Oilers would have easily finished last again without Talbot in net. That said, I never like the idea of overworking goalies but McLellan is very much a one goalie guy and between him and Chia I'm sure they don't see much of a need for a solid backup.
I do question going hard with one goalie, Talbots only fallbacks last year occurred through overuse. When he was simply seeing too many pucks in too many games. Let me emphasize that Oilers see a ton of rubber.
Theres no way we should be expecting 70 games out of Talbot. I don't think it wise for any team to do that really and what used to be considered untenable is for some reason occurring so regularly. To the detriment of goalies around the league. A top goalie should be seeing around 50- 60 games and that's what it used to be. Now they're much more likely to be getting shellshocked with 70 or so games. Doesn't make it right. I could right a book on this but orgs, coaches, are leveraging every drop they can out of goalies trying to eke out results. Which results in a lot of #1 being exhausted come playoff time. (Quick for example) This also greatly hampers backup goalie development as teams run starters ragged.
I believe that this one goalie trend is cap related. Teams spend big on their starter and find whatever they can fill with the backups. Can't believe how casually the most important position in hockey is treated.
next, look at teams that had success in playoffs. Pittsburgh went all the way with their backup. SJ went all the way with Jones who was able to handle the load because it was the first time ever. Don't expect him to be able to do it twice. Tampa, Bishop gets injured and thus Vasi comes in (solid 1/2)
I would never leverage the farm on one adequate goalie. Oilers fans more than anybody should know the results of that.