Proposal: Oilers - Devils (Subban and Hall to EDM)

[Stephen Gionta]

To Oilers:
Taylor Hall (3 million retained - 3 million cap hit for EDM)
PK Subban (3 million retained - 6 million cap hit for EDM)
Mirco Mueller

To New Jersey:
Adam Larsson
Sam Gagner
Kris Russell
Philip Broberg
2020 1st round pick

Click to read more...

 

[M2Beezy]

How on earth did a Devils fan make this lopsided proposal favouring the Oilers????

 

[Sniper99]

are we even trying with some of these proposals anymore? Yikes.

 

[tony d]

I think Nurse, Klefblom and the Nuge would have to be included in a deal for Hall and Subban to the Oilers.

 

[Hockey Stick]

Devils get shafted AND retain 3 mil on Subban for 3 more years? Broberg will be good but they're going to be paying a lot of money to guys that won't help them, and that 1st rounder will be a late one

 

[MessierII]

I think Nurse, Klefblom and the Nuge would have to be included in a deal for Hall and Subban to the Oilers.

Why? Subban is terrible and has an awful contract. Hall is a rental.

 

[Joey Moss]

Shero got shafted in the Subban deal. He's clearly on the downswing. Hall is a UFA.

You don't trade assets like Broberg, 1st, Larsson for that.

 

[oXo Cube]

Are we extending Hall first?

Maybe I'm just a homer but I'm not moving Broberg and a 1st for a pending UFA and Subban's dead decaying husk.

EDIT: Kind of an afterthought but there is also a roadblock of Russell having a NMC(Thanks Chia!) that he won't waive.

 

[Barnaby]

It's like a Picasso. It looks terrible, but if you keep staring at it then it almost starts making sense.

 

[Oil Spill]

Yeah that's a big no from me, Oilers are far from ready to be giving picks and prospects and definitely not for a upcoming UFA and shell of a former Norris winner.

 

[Acetylene]

Both fanbases hates it. You´re clearly onto something, OP. Well played!

 

[TFHockey]

Yeah that's a big no from me, Oilers are far from ready to be giving picks and prospects and definitely not for a upcoming UFA and shell of a former Norris winner.

Yeah, the Oilers aren't in a position to make that kind of deal.

 

[Mtler in Toronto]

This does favor the Oilers but in fairness Pk is done. He's an average NHL dman now. Even at 3 million retained that's a crappy contract.

 

[Zajacs Bowl Cut]

oh my gosh. I mean, what the hell?

 

[YP44]

OP must really hate Subban (rightfully so IMO) and really like Broberg

 

[nzoilerfan]

Don't think Holland would be interested in a deal like this. Can't afford Subban AND Hall. And would screw up the expansion draft plans for the oilers.

PK Subban is a a fast diminishing asset a with how his play has been. How many poeple want to give up significant assets for a 9m cap hit that gets you 5pts in 23 games....

Some team like Colorado will load up and win the bidding for Taylor Hall. And Subban is maybe moved for another defender needing a change of scenery.

Oilers maybe add a 3C via unloading a defender and look more to next season to make more waves.

 

[GhostfaceWu]

lmao a signed Hall isn't even apart of the deal. Get real. Subban is a train wreck and NJ fans actually think they'll be able to get more for him than what they gave up after his horrible start to the year.

 

[Zajacs Bowl Cut]

lmao a signed Hall isn't even apart of the deal. Get real. Subban is a train wreck and NJ fans actually think they'll be able to get more for him than what they gave up after his horrible start to the year.

please do not lump this particular OP in with all NJD fans. We have told him time and time again that he doesn't really ever come up with fair trade proposals.

 

[WhiskeyYerTheDevils]

I like this from a devils perspective. Subban is horrible, Larsson would be a huge upgrade.

 

[Blackjack]

I kind of like this proposal, it's wild and all over the place. My favorite part is the inclusion of Mirco Mueller.

 

[TGWL]

How on earth did a Devils fan make this lopsided proposal favouring the Oilers????

I'm not sure I see a deal that really favors Edmonton here, especially going forward.
UFA Hall
and Subban...

Top Prospect, 1st, and top 4. D-man. Seems about right.

I'm not sure Subban's value at the cap hit is anywhere near value for the Oilers to bring back more than what's already included for Hall.

The rest of the pieces seem useless and are there for cap purposes so you can toy around with that.

 

[TT1]

How on earth did a Devils fan make this lopsided proposal favouring the Oilers????

is this sarcasm? this is brutal for EDM, Hall is a UFA and Subban is trending downnnnnn.

 

[Vader611]

People saying this is bad for devils is hillarious, lot to give up for a washed up Subban and rental Hall i get the retention and all but still yikes

 

[ChaoticOrange]

I think Nurse, Klefblom and the Nuge would have to be included in a deal for Hall and Subban to the Oilers.

because f*** our D corps, right?

no, that’s not happening. Kris Russell, first pairing defenceman, is not happening . All things considered Klefbom is much more valuable than Subban is.

as for OP, pass from Edmonton. The days of us pining for Subban are long gone, he’s all yours. Hall - sure let’s talk. Subban even 3 mil retained I want no part of.

 

[780il]

Disgustingly bad....

Broberg AND a 1st? Subban sucks ass now he's not good.