Proposal: NYR-EDM: 25th + 30th Overall for 10th Overall

[FoxyClean]

Wondering how Oilers fans would feel about this. Rangers would like another top 10 pick to be able to bolster the farm with top prospects. Edmonton would be able to draft two players who could be solid, cost-controlled parts of McDavid's prime. Would two late firsts be enough for #10?

Click to read more...

 

[Ragdoll]

I don’t think this does it for the Oilers. If that pick is traded, it’s going to be for actual roster player(s). Otherwise they just keep it, no need to downgrade imo if we’re not clearing space or adding a roster player.

 

[Mr Tadakichi]

Not a terrible offer, but we need wingers and offensive D-man right now. Maybe a pick and somebody ready to play would be better.

 

[Kamiccolo]

That's maybe a good offer to move into 15-20 IMO but nothing higher.

 

[ChaoticOrange]

Edmonton hasn’t exactly been great at finding later steals in the draft. I’m more confident with Keith Gretzky’s two drafts looking really strong but a pure picks offer wouldnt do it for me.

 

[Skolman]

No thanks.

25th + Kreider for Russell + 10th

RNH-Mcdavid
Kreider-Draisaitl

 

[bernmeister]

No thanks.

25th + Kreider for Russell + 10th

RNH-Mcdavid
Kreider-Draisaitl

not enough for Kreider

 

[Skolman]

not enough for Kreider

That's fine. 25 + 30 isn't enough to move into the top 10

 

[Shootertooter]

not enough for the 10OA

No on Kreider being part of the deal.

 

[Archangel]

Wondering how Oilers fans would feel about this. Rangers would like another top 10 pick to be able to bolster the farm with top prospects. Edmonton would be able to draft two players who could be solid, cost-controlled parts of McDavid's prime. Would two late firsts be enough for #10?

Too far to fall

 

[TorontoTrades]

30th isnt nearly enough to jump from 25 to 10.

 

[rockinghockey]

25, 30 and a roster player
Which players are available for the deal

 

[tgo0]

Those picks alone would get somewhere in the late teens I assume, not 10OA.

If a roster player (maybe instead of 30OA??) or future 1st was added then maybe

 

[Pierce Hawthorne]

Yeah 25 + 30 does not get you into the Top 10.

It could get you up to ~15th overall but not any higher then that.


For example depending on how the draft goes down and who's on board at #16, I would probably move 16 for 25 and 30 if a couple guys I like in that 15 range are off the board(Kotkaniemi, Denisenko, and Kravtsov being the big 3, Hayton and Lundestrom as well).

If all of those guys were gone I'd probably move down to 25 and 30 in hopes of getting a couple Serron Noel/Martin Kaut/Dominik Bokk/Jet Woo/K'Andre Miller type of prospects in that range.

 

[Lays]

No thanks.

25th + Kreider for Russell + 10th

RNH-Mcdavid
Kreider-Draisaitl

You’re not getting Kreider alone for that..

 

[Skolman]

You’re not getting Kreider alone for that..

Rangers would absolutely do Kreider for the 10th overal pick

 

[Panda Bear]

 

[Lays]

Rangers would absolutely do Kreider for the 10th overal pick

Russell was in that deal too
Maybe we would, maybe we wouldn’t. I wouldn’t though
I’d rather hold onto those picks(unless someone falls), like everyone has said, doubt we’re getting higher than 15ish for those picks. I’d be open to moving the 2 later ones for a pair of 2nds though if anyone is interested (MTL?)

 

[Panda Bear]

So yeah, if you have another pick in the 30's up to #40, that would come close to being good enough.

 

[Skolman]

25 + 30 + 39 would be pretty damn tempting. I'd do it value wise

Oilers are not the team in a great position to do such a trade though

 

[Joey Moss]

Obviously 25 and 30 does not equal 10 value wise.

Brutal.

 

[Blackjack]

So yeah, if you have another pick in the 30's up to #40, that would come close to being good enough.

According to that chart, the 1OA is worth a thousand 7th rounders. Let's say that in a league with about 30 teams, that's more than 30 years worth of 7th round picks. Here's what 30 years of 7th round picks (1984-2013) looks like:

Palat-Pavelski-Marchant
Haula-Kamensky-Brouwer
Brunette-Ronning-Axelsson

Braun-Demers
Gunnarsson-Oduya

Lundqvist
Andersen

This isn't really directed at you, I just think it's funny how much early picks are overvalued, and late picks are undervalued across the board.

 

[t0nedeff]

25 + 30 + 39 would be pretty damn tempting. I'd do it value wise

Oilers are not the team in a great position to do such a trade though

You don't jump 15 spots into the top 10 by dangling what is essentially 2 2nd rounders and a very late first.

 

[Jayan]

No thanks.

25th + Kreider for Russell + 10th

RNH-Mcdavid
Kreider-Draisaitl

Kreider not on the block.

 

[Blackjack]

Kreider not on the block.

Good synergy between post and avatar here.