Nurse vs Hamilton vs Jones

[Figgie]

Which one would you take?

Click to read more...

 

[Boreal01]

Hamilton without any hesitation

 

[Nemesis Prime]

They are all bad.

 

[5 14 6 1]

I'll gladly take Nurse as someone who watches him every night. Hamilton is a good player though.

 

[Paper]

The best player with the lowest cap-hit...

I mean this poll will get locked for being too lopsided in about 5 minutes lol.

 

[Iggys Dome]

Hamilton AINEC

 

[Hisch13r]

This is not close. Dougie's easily the best player, he's the cheapest, and it's 7 years rather than 8.

 

[JaegerDice]

Hamilton is the best player at the lowest cap hit. Obviously you take him.

 

[1specter]

It's a joke that Nurse, Jones and Werenski are making more than Hamilton and Makar.

 

[Hisch13r]

It's a joke that Nurse, Jones and Werenski are making more than Hamilton and Makar.

Werenski is definitely overpaid by like ~1.5 mil but at least you're only paying him until he's 30 rather than until 35 for Jones, 34 for Nurse, and he's a better player

 

[Dabruins]

There is more to a player than just his contract numbers or point totals. To me, these are all good youngish 1 or 2 Dmen. However, Hamilton has been traded twice and left another team. He did not get a long well with coach/management and some players for the Bruins. I'm guessing the same thing happened in Calgary otherwise they hold onto him.

Seth Jones has been traded twice as well now. By all accounts he isn't a problem team mate or anything but obviously a little more to deal with than your average player.

Give me the guy that is loved by his team mates, management, and fans. Stayed loyal to the team that drafted him. I think Nurse would contribute the most to his team winning a cup than the other two. I take him. All great individual players though.

 

[Diamonddog01]

Hamilton is the only one.

 

[Hisch13r]

There is more to a player than just his contract numbers or point totals. To me, these are all good youngish 1 or 2 Dmen. However, Hamilton has been traded twice and left another team. He did not get a long well with coach/management and some players for the Bruins. I'm guessing the same thing happened in Calgary otherwise they hold onto him.

Seth Jones has been traded twice as well now. By all accounts he isn't a problem team mate or anything but obviously a little more to deal with than your average player.

Give me the guy that is loved by his team mates, management, and fans. Stayed loyal to the team that drafted him. I think Nurse would contribute the most to his team winning a cup than the other two. I take him. All great individual players though.

The reason Dougie got moved was always dumb and him walking out of Carolina because they lowballed the f*** out of him isn't a negative

lol I would too if they're handing me that contract.

 

[North Cole]

Hams > Nurse > Jones.

 

[JaegerDice]

There is more to a player than just his contract numbers or point totals. To me, these are all good youngish 1 or 2 Dmen. However, Hamilton has been traded twice and left another team. He did not get a long well with coach/management and some players for the Bruins. I'm guessing the same thing happened in Calgary otherwise they hold onto him.

Seth Jones has been traded twice as well now. By all accounts he isn't a problem team mate or anything but obviously a little more to deal with than your average player.

Give me the guy that is loved by his team mates, management, and fans. Stayed loyal to the team that drafted him. I think Nurse would contribute the most to his team winning a cup than the other two. I take him. All great individual players though.

 

[Tryamw]

Which one would you take?

Of these Choices? Hamilton.. But all 3 aren't worth it..

 

[rodney dangerfield]

most of you are taking dougie just because he makes freakin 500k less.

 

[Wierzbowski426]

most of you are taking dougie just because he makes freakin 500k less.

Or because he's the best of the 3?

 

[Hisch13r]

most of you are taking dougie just because he makes freakin 500k less.

And because he's far better and has one fewer year on his deal but that's irrelevant I guess. He's the only one worth his deal.

 

[holy]

Jones, but they’re all overpaid. None of these guys are winners, let’s see if they can change that, I’ll be damned called a grown man Dougie.

 

[Foppberg]

Jones.

 

[DJJones]

I'd take Jones. I don't get how he gets so much shit while Hamilton seems to just have criticism's glide off of him.

 

[Dabruins]

The reason Dougie got moved was always dumb and him walking out of Carolina because they lowballed the f*** out of him isn't a negative

lol I would too if they're handing me that contract.

My man, teams don't trade their own drafted stud players unless there are off ice issues (trouble with law, personal life stuff, negative locker room stuff etc). Hamilton never gelled with the Bruins tight locker room full of leaders. It's not a coincidence that Hamilton hasn't played more than 3 seasons for any team in his 9 year career so far. I don't think you win cups with people like Dougie Hamilton, just my opinion. We will see how he does in Jersey.

 

[Poppy Whoa Sonnet]

Jones and Nurse contracts don't even start until 2022 season

 

[abo9]

Seth Jones' contract is actually good value. 26 years old and one of the best D-men in the league.

Then probably Hamilton since his contract is both shorter term AND AAV than Nurse.

Then Nurse

Jones > Hamilton > Nurse