But Pionk has already proven himself an nhler. I can give him a lot more leeway than the guy who is still trying out for a position. Forbort’s 1st period was much better. He saved a goal that would have got past Helly. In order for Niku to do something equally impressive in the offensive end he would need to score a goal which he didn’t.
In fact Niku was the only guy trying out for a position. Beaulieu supporters can point to where he was one of our best d in the play ins last year against Calgary. Niku doesn’t have that. All he can point to is his performance in the A because the most generous you can say is he was alright and alright is blowing down the doors and earning you a spot over the incumbent.
You don't even have to go that far back. Go to the preseason scrimmage, where Beaulieu-De Melo basically shut down our top 6 forwards. Niku got torched by Luoto, beaten back to the net by Appleton, and gave up a good scoring chance to Lewis.
He might be a good guy to kick a soccer ball around with in a pregame warmup, and a decent skating and passing defenseman, when he is on, but then his defensive metrics are worse than Mark Stuart's. It's hard to justify playing him.
I don't see a future for him here, unless he solidifies his game. Because Ville Heinola can bring just about every element to the team that Sami Niku can, and probably more.
Beaulieu naysayers can hope for Samberg to replace him.
I am not writing Niku off yet. But I am apprehensive about his ability to be a full time NHL defenseman.