New Head Coach search

ZYXWVUT

Registered User
Feb 26, 2024
399
439
i'll add disco dan to my list of acceptable coaches, in place of sullivan who i'd give a .5% chance of not returning to pittsburgh. vellucci, berube, bylsma, boudreau, leach. dark and unlikely horse, savard.

I’ve been on the Vellucci train at least as someone who should be in the mix.
 

bossram

Registered User
Sep 25, 2013
15,763
15,314
Victoria
If there’s one thing that needs to be changed right away, it is the defensive zone. The Blues are one of the worst teams in the NHL at defending the slot, allowing a higher percentage of chances from there than almost every team. Armstrong alluded to that when asked about his defencemen: “When our team game suffers, (our defence) and our goalie looks the worst. And our variance on a nightly basis is concerning.”

32 Thoughts: What’s next for the Blues after Craig Berube firing? – Sportsnet.ca

Outside of binnington catching fire has didn’t really do much

They were near the 15-20 range at 5 on 5 most of his time there too
Most of his time in St. Louis (especially more recent seasons), his blueline personnel was atrocious.

Their Cup-winning season, the Blues were 3rd best in xGA/60. Likely should have been 2nd, as the the Wild by far had the lowest xGA/60 that season, but several analytics folks noted there was very dubious shot location tracking at the Wild's home rink for a few seasons.

In Berube's 2nd season (their last with Pietrangelo), the Blues were 8th in xGA/60.

My preference for Berube is largely related to his flexibility. He transitioned their style of play dramatically as his roster turned over. Going from a defensive, forecheck-based team a more rush-based, east-west attack under the Thomas/Kyrou core.
 

NjDevsRR

Hard To Find
Sponsor
Apr 24, 2012
28,958
58,079
Belmar
I'd rather see a rubber Dano mask slapped onto a Furby thats tied into Bing AI or Chat GPT (not even the good subscription ones, the free crap) behind the bench than half of these retreads mentioned, yuck.
I got you fam

IMG_5016.jpeg
 

Goptor

Registered User
Jun 30, 2016
2,351
2,789
Bylsma doesn't know how to coach hockey. He's a glorified gym trainer.

He's the reason Shero got fired from Pittsburgh and he managed to screw up with the 2 best centers in the league at their absolute best. Went to Buffalo and did the exact same thing as he did with the Penguins

Only positive is the players will love having him as their coach (if they can ignore the losses).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Whaddagoal

PizzaAndPucks

New Jersey Angels diehard
Nov 29, 2018
2,802
4,353
There has to be an assistant coach on a team that would be worth looking to bring in as well. AHL head coach , college etc...a new voice with no affiliation is what this team really needs but they need to have a winning pedigree as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: guitarguyvic

TBF1972

Registered User
May 19, 2018
7,979
6,417
Well under my stewardship a new captain will get masterful performances from Haula and Palat by yelling and throwing things around the locker room. I’m sure that will improve the team defense and reduce the injuries that have plagued the team.
if we want throwing things around and reduce injury at the same time, we need a captain who shoots wide.
 
  • Like
Reactions: My3Sons

BurntToast

Registered User
May 27, 2007
3,409
2,724
Saratoga, New York
Jay Leach (via B/R):

The former defenseman had a positive hand in getting Charlie McAvoy, Connor Clifton, and Jeremy Lauzon among other NHL blueliners ready for the NHL. Leach is a great communicator and thinker of the game.

Screw Bylsma, get his protege:
Jessica Campbell:

It would be trendy. Campbell's expertise in skating and skill training. Let’s make the Devils fast again.

Mike Velluci:

He's extremely well-rounded with experience in front-office and developmental roles along with his coaching.

Source:




Maybe we should do a poll, just to keep track of everyones top 10.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Guadana

SteveCangialosi123

Registered User
Feb 17, 2012
28,263
48,896
NJ
Defense could be better but that’s a very solid forward corps.

Eichel, ROR, Reinhart, E Kane. Okposo was still in his prime.

I’m still cool with Bylsma though his track record is not the best of the available candidates.
If it was prime Eichel and Reinhart that would be a good forward core. But they were 20 and 21.
 

Guttersniped

I like goalies who stop the puck
Sponsor
Dec 20, 2018
21,994
47,807
Defense could be better but that’s a very solid forward corps.

Eichel, ROR, Reinhart, E Kane. Okposo was still in his prime.

I’m still cool with Bylsma though his track record is not the best of the available candidates.


If it was prime Eichel and Reinhart that would be a good forward core. But they were 20 and 21.

Eichel missed the first 21 games when got a high ankle sprain in practice, right before opening night, which is a tough injury to come back from.

Then on opening night Evander Kane crashed into the boards and cracked a few ribs. He didn’t miss that much time but that likely contributed to his slow start w/ scoring.

2016-17 was a weird, cursed season for the Sabres. Well, maybe not that weird, since cursed is very on-brand for them.

Most of the top forwards had odd injuries O’Reilly: Emergency Appendectomy
Oposo: “Mystery Illness” that turned out to be a concussion combined w/ bad reaction to a medication

The team’s biggest issue was their newly built defense was hit hard by injury and imploded, bunch of those guys bombed out of Buffalo relatively quickly.

Bogosian and Kulikov missed significant time with injuries. Cody Franson’s and Josh Gorges’ careers died Buffalo.

The injuries and poor performances meant 22 year old Ristolainen and a 23 year old Jake McCabe were the team’s top two defensemen.

So yeah, you could say “the defense could be better” about the 2016-17 Sabres. (The goaltending was great though.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Guadana and My3Sons

Bleedred

Travis Green BLOWS! Bring back Nasreddine!
Sponsor
May 1, 2011
130,722
58,363
Most of the criticism and unfavorable opinions on Disco Dan started well before that stint in Buffalo.

They began in Pittsburgh, and several years before his firing.

They underachieved quite a bit in the playoffs after he won the 2009 (He won the cup, so he must be good, blah blah blah!) cup and a lot of that was on Fleury, who had several epic meltdowns along the way during those years, Some of them were on par with Vitek last year. Bylsma was always looked at as a JAG, who caught fire with Crosby/Malkin/Letang at the right time. The team did make the finals the year before under Therrien, who got fired down the final stretch and replaced with Bylsma.

Not too long after they fired him and hired a real coach (who has now become persona non grata among Pens fans lol) they won two cups in a row.

But not before they hired a JOKE coach in between (I always forget his name, but he looked like he worked in a funeral home) and easily getting blown over and turned upside down by the Rangers, and that was even with a solid series out of Fleury for the first time in many years.

For all we know Bylsma may be a better coach this time around than he was when he won the cup not even 50 games after becoming a head coach for the first time in the league.

He's kind of just in the ''Better than Travis Green'' bin for me, along with almost every hockey coach on the planet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: My3Sons

jkrdevil

UnRegistered User
Apr 24, 2006
42,863
12,773
Miami
I feel like the Olympics in 2014 killed Bylsma’s reputation. I remember reading that a lot of the US players walked away unhappy with the system the played, especially against Canada. Add on top of that the Penguins getting manhandled by the Bruins in 2013 playoff and then their 2014 exit that got Shero (and Bylsma) fired.
 

Guttersniped

I like goalies who stop the puck
Sponsor
Dec 20, 2018
21,994
47,807
Most of the criticism and unfavorable opinions on Disco Dan started well before that stint in Buffalo.

They began in Pittsburgh, and several years before his firing.

They underachieved quite a bit in the playoffs after he won the 2009 (He won the cup, so he must be good, blah blah blah!) cup and a lot of that was on Fleury, who had several epic meltdowns along the way during those years, Some of them were on par with Vitek last year. Bylsma was always looked at as a JAG, who caught fire with Crosby/Malkin/Letang at the right time. The team did make the finals the year before under Therrien, who got fired down the final stretch and replaced with Bylsma.

Not too long after they fired him and hired a real coach (who has now become persona non grata among Pens fans lol) they won two cups in a row.

But not before they hired a JOKE coach in between (I always forget his name, but he looked like he worked in a funeral home) and easily getting blown over and turned upside down by the Rangers, and that was even with a solid series out of Fleury for the first time in many years.

For all we know Bylsma may be a better coach this time around than he was when he won the cup not even 50 games after becoming a head coach for the first time in the league.

He's kind of just in the ''Better than Travis Green'' bin for me, along with almost every hockey coach on the planet.

I wrote “Injuries kill any real playoff hope a lot of years after the first Cup in 2009.”

Then, as I’m wont to do, I looked it up and that was less of thing than I remembered. Pretty much once in 5 years.

2010: 2nd Rd L, 3-4 MTL
just a regular old loss

2011: 1st Rd L, 3-4 TBL
No Crosby or Malkin in playoffs

2012: 1st Rd L, 2-4 PHI
The “I don’t like them because I don’t like any guy on their team” series
A wild one, endless brawls and penalties, and goals, goals, goals.
All those goals meant bad goaltending and Fleury won the bad goalie anti-duel.

2013: ECF L, 4-0 BOS
It happens

2014: 2nd Rd L, 4-3 NYR
A collapse after having a 3-1 lead gets everyone fired.
 

Bleedred

Travis Green BLOWS! Bring back Nasreddine!
Sponsor
May 1, 2011
130,722
58,363
I wrote “Injuries kill any real playoff hope a lot of years after the first Cup in 2009.”

Then, as I’m wont to do, I looked it up and that was less of thing than I remembered. Pretty much once in 5 years.

2010: 2nd Rd L, 3-4 MTL
just a regular old loss

2011: 1st Rd L, 3-4 TBL
No Crosby or Malkin in playoffs

2012: 1st Rd L, 2-4 PHI
The “I don’t like them because I don’t like any guy on their team” series
A wild one, endless brawls and penalties, and goals, goals, goals.
All those goals meant bad goaltending and Fleury won the bad goalie anti-duel.

2013: ECF L, 4-0 BOS
It happens

2014: 2nd Rd L, 4-3 NYR
A collapse after having a 3-1 lead gets everyone fired.
I remember 2013 was the Vokoun year. I remember Fleury starting the playoffs, but losing the job halfway through the first round against the Islanders (I think?) and he allowed a late goal in one of the games that was probably softy of the playoffs for that year. And it wasn't the only one.

I Vokoun entered that series when it was tied at 2 and they went on a pretty good run with him. I think they won the rest of the games in that Islanders series, then took down Ottawa in either 4 or 5. I remember it went pretty quickly. Then they stopped scoring and were swept by Boston, despite Vokoun still playing well. I swear they were shutout a couple of times in that 4 game series and I believe they lost at least one game in OT.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Guttersniped

jkrdevil

UnRegistered User
Apr 24, 2006
42,863
12,773
Miami
I wrote “Injuries kill any real playoff hope a lot of years after the first Cup in 2009.”

Then, as I’m wont to do, I looked it up and that was less of thing than I remembered. Pretty much once in 5 years.

2010: 2nd Rd L, 3-4 MTL
just a regular old loss

2011: 1st Rd L, 3-4 TBL
No Crosby or Malkin in playoffs

2012: 1st Rd L, 2-4 PHI
The “I don’t like them because I don’t like any guy on their team” series
A wild one, endless brawls and penalties, and goals, goals, goals.
All those goals meant bad goaltending and Fleury won the bad goalie anti-duel.

2013: ECF L, 4-0 BOS
It happens

2014: 2nd Rd L, 4-3 NYR
A collapse after having a 3-1 lead gets everyone fired.
It’s the combo in short order of that Bruins series in 2013 (that was the year they loaded up with Iginla, Doug Murray and I want to say Brendan Morrow), followed by the Olympic disaster vs Canada, followed by the collapse vs the Rangers. I’m a span of a year his reputation tumbled (remember when HBO portrayed him as the cerebral one vs Boudreau).

In Buffalo he apparently had a bad relationship with Eichel. Then he was part of Blashill’s go nowhere staffs in Detroit.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Guttersniped

NJDevs26

Once upon a time...
Mar 21, 2007
67,538
31,967
I wrote “Injuries kill any real playoff hope a lot of years after the first Cup in 2009.”

Then, as I’m wont to do, I looked it up and that was less of thing than I remembered. Pretty much once in 5 years.

2010: 2nd Rd L, 3-4 MTL
just a regular old loss

2011: 1st Rd L, 3-4 TBL
No Crosby or Malkin in playoffs

2012: 1st Rd L, 2-4 PHI
The “I don’t like them because I don’t like any guy on their team” series
A wild one, endless brawls and penalties, and goals, goals, goals.
All those goals meant bad goaltending and Fleury won the bad goalie anti-duel.

2013: ECF L, 4-0 BOS
It happens

2014: 2nd Rd L, 4-3 NYR
A collapse after having a 3-1 lead gets everyone fired.
Christ I forgot how bad some of those were...of course when you're not a fan of the team you basically forget within a year unless it's something REALLY shitty like the Louie Domingue disaster.
 

Based Anime Fan

Himedanshi Bandit
Mar 11, 2012
7,560
6,287
Tokai
So what options to we have?

Not working atm:
Jay Woodcroft
Gerard Gallant
Guy-who-was-fired-from-Minnesota
Bruce

Could be pried:
Guy Boucher
Berube

Is Dineen still in Utica?
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad