Megustaelhockey
"I like hockey" in Spanish
- Apr 29, 2011
- 21,414
- 13,863
Are we saying that ^^ this kind of raw emotion makes for the best type of captain, though? Why can't a team be successful with a quieter, admittedly less rah-rah kind of guy?
News Article: Nash on going back to Columbus, endorses McDonagh for Captain
- Thread starter Glen Sathers Cigar
- Start date
Nanaki
Registered User
That was my take when Dubinsky was here as well. I don't think that Callahan was that great of a captain either. I think Girardi would probably be the best choice for captain but I wouldn't be overly upset if it was Mcdonagh.
OverTheCap
Registered User
- Jan 3, 2009
- 10,454
- 184
Sure, I think if you have other guys in the locker room who are vocal and/or a coach who is a motivator, then a quieter type is fine. Scott Niedermayer and Joe Sakic were both considered quiet leaders.
However, if you have a team full of players that can't really self-motivate, then a quiet leader is not ideal. I think the Rangers generally perform better when they have someone to kick their butts into gear every now and then.
Am I the only one who thinks the captaincy is little more than some extra stitching on your jersey and the ability to talk to the referee?
Nanaki
Registered User
I think on a veteran team you are right. If you have a younger team having a veteran who can mentor players and show them the right way to do things is a lot more important.
This is one of those topics where everyone has a different opinion, and all of those opinions are correct depending on the situation. In some team dynamics, the captaincy is exactly what you say here. You might have a whole team of guys moving in the same direction, with several guys taking the lead and the letters meaning little or nothing (I honestly think this was the case in 2011). Have a young team? Maybe a steady vet is the best option for a captain. A vet team? You might need a fiery guy to keep those vets from acting too complacent (paging Mr.'s Nash and Richards...).
Would Dubinsky make a good captain? Yes, he would on a team that needs a passionate guy to lead the way. Some rosters, he would be a detriment as a captain.
The C can mean a lot of things (or absolutely nothing). It's all situational.
I agree, but I also think NY fans got spoiled by Messier in his first stint here.
He had the ability to singlehandedly change the demeanor and attitude of his teammates. Very very few athletes have that ability.
cbjgirl
Just thinking
This is part of the reason why Dubinsky having the C would be a problem in my eyes. The C needs to be capable of being the voice of reason when the team is pissed off at the game circumstances. (just my opinion, of course). Last thing you need is an officiating group that hates your captain.
For most fans, the qualification for wearing a letter boils down to one thing: A guy who gets as angry as they do when the team plays badly.
Being a captain on a small market team going no where for years on end is not the same as being captain on team in the biggest market in the world.
Does this really surprise people?
No distractions needed for this guy. Just focus on putting the puck in the net Rick.
Does this really surprise people?
No distractions needed for this guy. Just focus on putting the puck in the net Rick.
haveandare
Registered User
Agreed. Granted we only have a tiny window into who these guys really are, everything I've read about and seen from McD suggests that he's a very mature guy who works real hard to be the best athlete he can be. I mean, look at his conditioning. He's had bad games and bad stretches for sure, but I can't recall even one game where I thought he looked like he was dogging it, or wasn't up to the physical challenge. He's a pretty big guy for his height, yet he skates so effortlessly. I'd imagine that takes a lot of work on both sides of the equation - in the weight room and on the ice.
I'm not set on anybody as the next captain really, as I don't know nearly enough about what goes on in the room, but I'd be happy with any of McD/Girardi/Staal. All 3 have stepped up for this team countless times. All 3 have been loyal to the organization. All 3 seem like smart, mature guys.
I don't think this team has that vocal leader that some people want. I don't think most teams do, frankly. Those type of personalities are rare in the world, even in a situation like this, where everyone has had to work hard for years and show extremely dedication just to get here. In lieu of that type of guy, pick someone with a good head on their shoulders, someone who can cool everyone off when they're too worked up and fire everyone up when they're too carless. Most importantly, pick someone who you know will never be caught giving less than 100% on the ice. I think any of those 3 d-men are more than capable of that.
Inferno
Registered User
Lidstrom captained the Red Wings...he never struck me as a guy who was rah rah.
one of the greatest players to play the game, and captained his team to a championship.
one of the greatest players to play the game, and captained his team to a championship.
Pavel Buchnevich
Drury and Laviolette Must Go
YoSoyLalo
me reading HF
Because Leetch was that type of player and perceived as a weak captain so that means it will always happen
Not to nit pick, but are we comparing Rick Nash to Nick Lindstrom? I'm not trashing Nash here, but the record is clear as to what the Jackets achieved during his captaincy.
He and the franchise would be far better served by him having a much narrower focus. Just score more goals and be a better all round player. There by making the players around him better performers in the bargain.
That's a great and much more suitable leadership role for him.
Seems to me like the most consistently good choice for captain is the best player on the team. Toews, Chara, Crosby, Lidstrom, Neidermeyer have all fit that description and won the cup recently. The most notable exception is Dustin Brown, but I'd say it's hardly a rule. Look around the league--most teams choose their best player to be their captain. That's why I think McDonagh would be the clear best choice, not because he has more or less of an off ice presence
Kaapo di tutti capi
Registered User
we want cup
Registered User
Wait... people are really talking about Nash as captain?
I would make Boyle the captain before Nash.
I would make Boyle the captain before Nash.
Glen Sathers Cigar
Sather 4 Ever
Nash himself scoffed at the notion. He endorsed McDonagh. If anything, people in this thread have attacked Nash.
Chaels Arms
Formerly Lias Andersson
Ad
Latest posts
-
-
Around the League Thread | Stop f***ing crying, bro, this isn’t Junior.- Latest: theguardianII
-
