Matthews+Marner+Point vs Rantanen+Laine+Kane

[Sky04]

Oh I’m sure he is. Difference is I provide evidence and reasoning for my opinions.

Flawed logic, horrible reasoning due to inability to contextualize doesn't count.

Voted Rantanen,

 

[VoluntaryDom]

"Despite having MacKinnon"? Check MacKinnons stats away from Rantanen? MacKinnon and Landy suddenly exploded when they gor Rantanen on their line. Isnt that odd?

Landeskog 33p in 2016-2017
MacKinnon 53p in 2016-2017

Full-time with Rantanen

MacKinnon 97p 2017-2018
Landeskog 62p 2017-2018

Any 2nd liner has that kind of impact on linemates...

last i checked mackinnon has a 10% p/60 drop away from rants and rants has a 50% drop away from mack

 

[winnipegger]

So the one with the Art Ross leader and #2 in goals and Patrick Kane is losing. huh?

 

[Leafidelity]

Did you mean Kase?

 

[1OApick]

Rantanen > Matthews
Laine >/>> Marner
Kane <Point

 

[koyvoo]

Did you mean Kase?

Well if it is Kase, I’m changing my vote to his trio.

 

[Pyrophorus]

The line with 2 centres

Its how it goes, right?

 

[jonlin]

The line with 2 centres

Its how it goes, right?

Rantanen-Laine-Kane??? Laine and Rantanen are the 2 players Dominic hates most, so obviously he puts out a line that never would work. I`d take option A 11 times of 10, because the centers. This poll is stupid. Give Kane and Rants a center and its much closer. Its like

WHO do you take for 1st line:

Grubauer-McDavid-Josi

vs.

Marchand-MacKinnon-Pasternak

 

[member 151739]

Three wingers vs. two centers and a winger. Legit.

 

[bobholly39]

Rantanen-Laine-Kane??? Laine and Rantanen are the 2 players Dominic hates most, so obviously he puts out a line that never would work. I`d take option A 11 times of 10, because the centers. This poll is stupid. Give Kane and Rants a center and its much closer. Its like

WHO do you take for 1st line:

Grubauer-McDavid-Josi

vs.

Marchand-MacKinnon-Pasternak

McDavid.

You?

 

[Backcheckmonster3]

which trio is currently better

What a weird poll, comparing 2c and 1 winger vs 3 wingers, i mean to you Rantanen is a middle six winger, which in that case would make this poll even more weird.
[MOD]

 

[TomasHertlsRooster]

last i checked mackinnon has a 10% p/60 drop away from rants and rants has a 50% drop away from mack

What kind of sample sizes are we looking at here?

 

[Binister]

What kind of sample sizes are we looking at here?

I don't know but those hot takes he make can't be taken serious.

 

[Eternal Leaf]

Did you mean Kase?

Kase/Evander Kane don't play in the Central division (OP's poll asked Atlantic vs Central).

So he clearly means Patty Kane.

 

[TruePowerSlave]

Laine brings down the Central trio and they are all wingers for some reason.

 

[Hint1k]

Atlantic trio scored 43 goals this season.
Central - 49 goals.
And a player's ability to stay healthy is the same thing as player's size, speed, shooting etc.

So Central trio is better so far.

 

[TruePowerSlave]

Atlantic trio scored 43 goals this season.
Central - 49 goals.
And a player's ability to stay healthy is the same thing as player's size, speed, shooting etc.

So Central trio is better so far.

Judging players only by goals is laughable.

 

[The List Of Jericho]

Rantanen > Matthews
Laine >/>> Marner
Kane <Point

Hilarious...you should do stand up

 

[Howie Hodge]

Not much Point to this thread.......

 

[Hint1k]

Judging players only by goals is laughable.

When NHL / IIHF start counting something other than goals to define a winner of a game then we talk again.

 

[TruePowerSlave]

When NHL / IIHF start counting something other than goals to define a winner of a game then we talk again.

So you are saying that the winner of the Maurice Richard is automatically the best player in hockey, after all he does score more goals than anyone else.

 

[Hint1k]

So you are saying that the winner of the Maurice Richard is automatically the best player in hockey, after all he does score more goals than anyone else.

It is not me saying this it is the reality of the hockey game.

 

[authentic]

It is not me saying this it is the reality of the hockey game.

Lol.

 

[Hint1k]

Lol.

What happened? Those nasty facts refused to support your theories? Try to base your theories on facts next time.

 

[TruePowerSlave]

It is not me saying this it is the reality of the hockey game.

Then why doesn't the Richard winner often not win the Ted Lindsay or the Hart?