I couldn't really follow the Sharks cup run closely. Only managed to catch the highlights from the games. So could you guys tell me if our players (Polak, Spaling and Reimer) managed to pay themselves off for the price the Sharks paid? I know that one of the seconds was really for Reimer and there was huge discussion in the follow up trade about which pick was exactly for who. So if you guys followed, did our boys help the Sharks reach the finals? I guess if you reach the finals the trades you make are good, but seemed like an over payment at the time and I am very happy with our picks. Thanks! : )
Sharks fan here.
Spaling has been the best of the three in the playoffs (although that's not fair to Reimer). He has some speed and plays a good 200 foot game. He's played some crucial minutes late in games. DeBoer loves him and hes been excellent on our 4th line.
Reimer was great during the regular season. He gave Jones a rest and a chance to win the games where Jones isn't playing. I haven't seen a goalie ever look more scrambley and nervous in net yet put up such great numbers. He's going to get paid this summer and he deserves it.
Polak took some adjusting. His pairing (Dillon-Polak) has put up some pretty brutal corsi numbers but hes been great on the PK. I don't think it was a great deal for us (although it was likely a handshake deal for the Reimer trade), but Polak has brought value. Once every few shifts you seem him break the zone and rush the puck like Brent Burns. He looks like a man on a mission. Also, no one wants to be a net front presence with him and Dillon there.
TLDR: All three have helped us get to were we are today. We likely overpaid but its worth it right now. I don't see any of them staying past this year though.