Dingle
summer is gone
- Nov 22, 2019
- 765
- 208
The criticism is to the "we are in trouble if they don't work out" comments. Well, it would hurt sure, but we have depth and could survive it. That's very different than throwing them overboard. These guys are good and valued prospects, nothing less, nothing more. These guys aren't as important as Tkachuk, or likely our two picks this season. They are no more important to the team than Brannstrom's success and frankly likely less important. That doesn't mean I or anyone else who isn't placing them in the same category as Redden or Phillips is giving up on them. It's just being realistic. The hope is they become top 4 Dmen, not franchise Dmen (though that would be nice).
I also disagree that they need to be up here asap, to the contrary, I think a patient development path is best for them. Paving the path for them to succeed, which I think we can all agree would be ideal, to me means ensuring that they come up when they are ready, not because we don't have anyone else, not because we want to get them into some critical path as you are saying. We won't bury them in the minors, we want to develop them there so they can maximize their long term impact.
their importance is on par with Redden and Philips. And being drafted #1 or #2 as a Dman, is no where near a complement to your stature. We may never know, but Gretzky would have most likely been #1, Lemieux, Crosby, OVI, in time McDavid......#1 forwards are typically much more valuable. #1 D men, not as much. Ray Bourque, Nick Lindstrom, Chara, EK, etc. are not #1. In fact Lindstrom was a 3rd round, as was Chara..#1's have been apt to be Aaron Ekblad.
It is why, I believe that two guys, drafted in the first round in subsequent years, may prove to be the cornerstone of this franchise..along with Chabot. This team's BIG THREE.
I return to my original post, which touched off this storm: YES, I very much believe the team's eggs are in those two baskets. If these two remotely materialize into the modern version of Redden (Thompson) and Philips (JBD). This could be 1998 all over again. If they don't, I am not as confident as you are, that they can overcome it.
the team wants us to laud their picks..but not too hard, just encase they fail, then we don't blame them... They want us to praise the pick, declare victory, but not question if after things fall apart. They want us to love them, then forgive all indiscretions if they misbehave!!!
Jees Mick, they wonder why outside of their bubble they are not trusted, or are disliked.