still a bust in my eyes. 40 points in year 4 for a top 4 pick isnt great.
Meh... it's the way he's playing that is helpful. A solid two-way game.
He's not a dynamic offensive force, but he's a huge body who is learning how to use it. Lots of raw power to still harness.
Here are a few top 4 picks since the 1990 draft who also didn't score 40 until their D+4 season:
Keith Primeau - retired with 623 pts in 909 gp
Radek Bonk - retired with 497 pts in 969 gp
JP Dumont - retired with 523 pts in 823 gp
Olli Jokinen - retired with 750 in 1231 gp
BOTH SEDINS - retired with over 1000 points each
Andrew Ladd - retired with 538 in 950 gp
Bobby Ryan - 569 pts in 866 gp
James Van Reimsdyk - 520 in 794 gp
Ryan Johansen - 462 in 706
Jonathan Drouin - 232 in 393
Dylan Strome - 120 in 204
That's 12 guys from 1990 - 2015, so one every other year or so.
Sedins an obviously outlier, but there are a lot of big, gangly, players in that list that needed time to grow into their frame. Many on the list ended up as solid two-way, imposing forwards with plenty of 50-60 point seasons under their belt.
I think that would be a big win for the oilers. Lots of interesting comparables.