A lot of people seem to be putting him on top five or top ten lists. He was incredible last season, but it's the first truly elite season he has had. Giroux has more elite seasons than MacKinnon and he outscored him even last season. What is the rationale for putting him in the top five or ten and not also considering Hall and Giroux to be top five or top ten players? That Giroux is older and less likely to replicate his performance from last season? Hall beat MacK for the Hart last season and was as good or better in each of the previous four seasons. Is it too soon to call MacK a top five or top ten player in the NHL?