TheDevilMadeMe
Registered User
I didn't say that Iginla's regular season results trump those of Moore. I was mainly showing that they were comparable, at least in terms of offensive production. As I said earlier I still consider Moore to be superior.
I don't know how much consideration I would give to playoff performance with these two players. Iginla generally played on middling Calgary teams, while Moore played on the greatest team in hockey history. As a result, Iginla only had one playoff run that extended beyond the first round while Moore had seven. That being said, Moore's playoff results were somewhat more impressive, though not hugely so. I believe a playoff comparison would be much more valuable when comparing Moore and Cournoyer.
Yeah, I get that it's not really a fair comparison to Iginla - still Moore was a huge part of those playoff teams and does deserve credit for it.
As for comparing Moore to Cournoyer - I think that unless you place a huge amount of emphasis on longevity, Moore is so obviously the better player than you don't even have to get into playoff performances.