Seachd
Registered User
- Mar 16, 2002
- 24,939
- 8,947
Or maybe MacT replaces Howson.Good for him, and good to see that OBC being slowly dismantled.
Meh, I never got the hate for MacT. Players loved playing for him as a coach.Or maybe MacT replaces Howson.
Fired as coach, hired as GM. 'Trades are hard'. 'Visually better.' 'Bold moves'. Nikitin, Ference, Eakins, The Krueger debacle. Failed to improve the system, continued failure in terms of draft and development.Meh, I never got the hate for MacT. Players loved playing for him as a coach.
As a GM, his Perron for Paajarvi trade, then moving Perron for a 1st was great. Purcell for Gags at the time was a big win as well. The rest was all minor stuff. The only trade I'd knock him for was Petry, but he has become a far greater defenceman in Montreal than he ever was here. If you want to argue he didn't make enough blockbuster trades to improve the team, I don't think that was the goal of ownership or management at the time. We were horrific and needed to rebuild.
He's a good guy, and not one of the ones we should be including in with the likes of Lowe and Howson.
To be honest I don't mind MacT. But he is very much a symbol of the OBC and if he does come back a lot of people on here will lose their minds.Meh, I never got the hate for MacT. Players loved playing for him as a coach.
As a GM, his Perron for Paajarvi trade, then moving Perron for a 1st was great. Purcell for Gags at the time was a big win as well. The rest was all minor stuff. The only trade I'd knock him for was Petry, but he has become a far greater defenceman in Montreal than he ever was here. If you want to argue he didn't make enough blockbuster trades to improve the team, I don't think that was the goal of ownership or management at the time. We were horrific and needed to rebuild.
He's a good guy, and not one of the ones we should be including in with the likes of Lowe and Howson.
Nikitin was a gamble and we had tons of cap space with a complete trash roster he inherited. Wasn't that big of a loss. Team was obviously not trying to compete during that time, and signings like Nikitin are decent when you are trying to hit big and resell assets for picks during said rebuild. Not to mention every GM in the league has a history of overpaying at least a couple veteran guys who they know bring veteran leadership, something that us fans can't really comprehend without being in the room.Fired as coach, hired as GM. 'Trades are hard'. 'Visually better.' 'Bold moves'. Nikitin, Ference, Eakins, The Krueger debacle. Failed to improve the system, continued failure in terms of draft and development.
He was the poster boy for Oiler nepotism in the OBC era.
Probably a really interesting dude to have a discussion with--would assume he doesn't drink--but he deserves to be bunched in with the OBC. The guy keeps landing on his feet.
Good for him, and good to see that OBC being slowly dismantled.
Or maybe MacT replaces Howson.
We traded away a pick for the opportunity to sign Nikitin as a UFA. There was no committed rebuild in his time as a GM. If you asked him candidly, he'd tell you he was really trying to build a competitive product. The fact of the matter is that trades are hard and MacT was out of his element as an NHL GM.Nikitin was a gamble and we had tons of cap space with a complete trash roster he inherited. Wasn't that big of a loss. Team was obviously not trying to compete during that time, and signings like Nikitin are decent when you are trying to hit big and resell assets for picks during said rebuild. Not to mention every GM in the league has a history of overpaying at least a couple veteran guys who they know bring veteran leadership, something that us fans can't really comprehend without being in the room.
For my money he's a great hockey mind. Every player who played for him has talked about how great of a coach he was, how hard they battled for him. He, like Tambellini, were essentially told to stand pat and let our rebuild progress. I don't see that as a huge slight against them.
Nikitin was a gamble and we had tons of cap space with a complete trash roster he inherited. Wasn't that big of a loss. Team was obviously not trying to compete during that time, and signings like Nikitin are decent when you are trying to hit big and resell assets for picks during said rebuild. Not to mention every GM in the league has a history of overpaying at least a couple veteran guys who they know bring veteran leadership, something that us fans can't really comprehend without being in the room.
For my money he's a great hockey mind. Every player who played for him has talked about how great of a coach he was, how hard they battled for him. He, like Tambellini, were essentially told to stand pat and let our rebuild progress. I don't see that as a huge slight against them.
Meh, I never got the hate for MacT. Players loved playing for him as a coach.
As a GM, his Perron for Paajarvi trade, then moving Perron for a 1st was great. Purcell for Gags at the time was a big win as well. The rest was all minor stuff. The only trade I'd knock him for was Petry, but he has become a far greater defenceman in Montreal than he ever was here. If you want to argue he didn't make enough blockbuster trades to improve the team, I don't think that was the goal of ownership or management at the time. We were horrific and needed to rebuild.
He's a good guy, and not one of the ones we should be including in with the likes of Lowe and Howson.
Come on, toby and horcoff on the first line ? He was horrible. He still is. He will always be.Yeah I didn't think his tenure as coach or GM was bad at all either. I don't think he necessarily hit it out if the park but he was probably the best GM we had during the decade of darkness. (Not saying that is hard either mind you)... Biggest knocks I have against him are Petry and Eakins. Pretty bad moves there.
Come on, toby and horcoff on the first line ? He was horrible. He still is. He will always be.
What about the 10 thousand other mistakes he made.This is just such an unbelievably asinine post. Peterson was never used in the top 6 for more than spot duty and things like that happen on nearly every team in the league. Horcoff was an excellent player who's play on the 1st line had the Oilers within inches of a Stanley Cup if not for Ward.