The reason I am lukewarm on the deal is that I don't think our "championship window" has even started yet. In three years it will, though, and that's when its even more important not to be larded with bad contracts.
I understand where you are coming from.
I think Hartnell and Horton for that matter can be core players the next 2-3 years, beyond that you start to get into mid 30's which for most players become much less productive years. 3 years from now, Hartnell will be 36 with 2 years remaining on contract, Horton 32 with 3 years remaining.That's 10 million dollars annually we'll have tied up in aging veterans. I hope they are still kicking ass, but history says they'll be on the decline.
It's a young man's game. Doughty(24), Carter(29), Kopitar(26), these are the big 3 LA rode to the cup this season. Granted they also had a pair of 32 year olds that produced very well in the post season. However both of those players have had some very non productive, injury laden seasons as well.
I think we can make deep runs the next 3 seasons, and that's a compliment to the current and previous management. Beyond that, we'll need some creative roster management to take the next step. The Hartnell contract is a microcosm of that reality imo.
In three years if Hartnell has deteriorated there is always the buyout. Cost would be 1.6 per for 4 years. I know the anti-buyout guys will cringe but it will be an affordable option to ditch his contract if need be.
Very good point.