hfboardsuser
Registered User
- Nov 18, 2004
- 12,280
- 0
Here's how I myself would rank them based both on in-season performance and consistency as a top performer.
Top 25:
1st- Bobby Orr '70 (Best season ever IMO)
2nd- Bobby Orr '72 (Close second, minus the Art Ross)
3rd- Wayne Gretzky '85
4th- Wayne Gretzky '86
5th- Dominik Hasek '98
6th- Dominik Hasek '97
7th- Phil Esposito '74
8th- Brett Hull '91
9th- Mario Lemieux '88
10th- Howie Morenz '28
11th- Wayne Gretzky '82
12th- Mario Lemieux '93
13th- Alex Ovechkin '08
14th- Jaromir Jagr '99
15th- Jacques Plante '62
16th- Sergei Fedorov '94
17th- Bobby Orr '71
18th- Bobby Clarke '76
19th- Jean Beliveau '56
20th- Joe Thornton '06
21st- Sidney Crosby '07
22nd- Bobby Hull '66
23rd- Bobby Clarke '72
24th- Bobby Clarke '76
25th- Maurice Richard '47
"Worst" 10:
68th- Ted Kennedy '52 (really odd one; 2nd on own team in points)
69th- Ebbie Goodfellow '40 (4th in pts among D and 2nd on team, but bad club and didn't appear to significantly help defensively)
70th- Babe Siebert '37 (lifetime achievement Hart)
71st- Billy Burch '25 (Perry with three more TTPs)
72nd- Frank Nighbor '24 (lifetime achievement Hart)
73rd- Chuck Rayner '50 (Hart yet 2nd team goalie?)
74th- Corey Perry '11 (too early in his career to judge fairly)
75rd- Al Rollins '54 (A singular Vezina otherwise)
76th- Roy Worters '29 (most puzzling IMO, but has career)
77th- Jose Theodore '02 (Never won another major award, nor was he even a SAST ever again)
Top 25:
1st- Bobby Orr '70 (Best season ever IMO)
2nd- Bobby Orr '72 (Close second, minus the Art Ross)
3rd- Wayne Gretzky '85
4th- Wayne Gretzky '86
5th- Dominik Hasek '98
6th- Dominik Hasek '97
7th- Phil Esposito '74
8th- Brett Hull '91
9th- Mario Lemieux '88
10th- Howie Morenz '28
11th- Wayne Gretzky '82
12th- Mario Lemieux '93
13th- Alex Ovechkin '08
14th- Jaromir Jagr '99
15th- Jacques Plante '62
16th- Sergei Fedorov '94
17th- Bobby Orr '71
18th- Bobby Clarke '76
19th- Jean Beliveau '56
20th- Joe Thornton '06
21st- Sidney Crosby '07
22nd- Bobby Hull '66
23rd- Bobby Clarke '72
24th- Bobby Clarke '76
25th- Maurice Richard '47
"Worst" 10:
68th- Ted Kennedy '52 (really odd one; 2nd on own team in points)
69th- Ebbie Goodfellow '40 (4th in pts among D and 2nd on team, but bad club and didn't appear to significantly help defensively)
70th- Babe Siebert '37 (lifetime achievement Hart)
71st- Billy Burch '25 (Perry with three more TTPs)
72nd- Frank Nighbor '24 (lifetime achievement Hart)
73rd- Chuck Rayner '50 (Hart yet 2nd team goalie?)
74th- Corey Perry '11 (too early in his career to judge fairly)
75rd- Al Rollins '54 (A singular Vezina otherwise)
76th- Roy Worters '29 (most puzzling IMO, but has career)
77th- Jose Theodore '02 (Never won another major award, nor was he even a SAST ever again)