Here we disagree. Eller is supposed to be more than a space-filler. He's been sold as a potentially productive 2nd or 3rd-liner, and he's done just that for chunks of the last two seasons. What we're seeing recently is a mentally defeated Eller who's lost his mojo. Even his defensive game is erratic and unmotivated. Some of the problem is linemates, but most is squarely on Eller himself, who appears less willing to commit his body and legs to the play. Something's not right with the guy, and I refuse to dump all blame on Therrien.
I refuse to blame Eller.
Look back at this kid's career and utilization. He has had to work the hardest out of everybody just get a sniff of offensive opportunities.
Every time he was given capable wingers, and more offensive opportunities, he's produced. This is an undeniable fact, not an opinion.
I understood keeping him back when we first acquired him. The way he improved his defensive game under Martin was quite evident. But even Martin knew to give him a little more chances and try him with better wingers in his 2nd year. It lead to him and AK finding some great chemistry. They owned their opposition. Then Martin got fired, RC took over and broke that up.
Last year, with a one week training camp, no exhibition games, under a new system, we lose our opening game to Toronto. The whole team looked bad, confused, and disorganized. Pretty normal considering the short camp and new system. Nonetheless, Eller is targeted by the coach and scratched. Before the season started, Therrien called out Eller saying it was a make or break year for him.
After being scratched for 2 games, he comes back on the 4th line. He plays well. He gets promoted, he gets tried as a winger, until finally they make him center Galy and Prust. It works really well. That line, along with the EGG line later, dominate their opponents. They are pulling the team on many nights and are our advantage going into the POs. He finishes with 30pts in 46gp, which usually is the production of 2nd line centers - top 6 talent, and does so without PP opportunities and limited ice time.
Finally, Eller has arrived. At least that's the belief.
This year starts, they pick up exactly where they left it. The EGG line does great together. Out of the first 20 games, these guys are split up a few times in order to help others produce. All in all, they play about 16-17 of the first games together.
They all are on the same point pace or more than the one of last season. Gallagher is in a very nice position to hit 30-35 goals.
Alas, they are split up again and this time, Gallagher stays on DD's wing. At that point, Eller's ice time starts to drop, the PP opportunities also diminishes until they pretty much are halted. At least Galchenyuk is still on Eller's wing, and that helps him maintain a .5 point ratio, which is very decent. But then, the production from the Plekanec line isn't where it should be, and Bourque is useless there.
So up Galchenyuk goes, Bourque is moved next to Eller.
Eller goes from having two good wingers, getting more ice time, PP opportunities, and producing, to having that cut up in half, and still, he produced, until finally, it was all taken away from him which lead to him not producing and looking pretty bad out there. And people are seriously trying to understand what is wrong??? Really?? Is it that difficult to figure out?
The guy had to bend over backwards to get better chances last year. Now people are expecting him to want to do the same thing again?? I can't blame him for not really being at the top of his game right now. What's the point?? They're not going to give him more offensive opportunities, no PP time, and his line will eventually be broken up.
If I'm Eller, I'm seriously pissed with the way I've been used this year. Going to work unhappy can easily be noticed. It makes a huge difference. That's what we're seeing from Eller imo.
He still battles hard, and does his job like a professional, but he isn't happy and it's reflective in his game.
It's all on Therrien. I'm not going to blame the kid for not making a rather mediocre Prust (this year) not produce, or not working well with a guy even Plekanec couldn't make work in Bourque, or not making Weise or Moen into scorers.