We should be expecting to win the Gold Cup, regardless of which players we field. It's true that maybe like 2 or 3 of those guys are in the best 23, but I still think that's a bad excuse. The Gold Cup field is a very weak one. You have to be winning it, whoever takes the field. Berhalter takes full blame for this one. He's not starting in September. He started in July, and he's on the hook for this. Players-wise, like half of this roster we knew should never play another game for the National Team before the tournament started, so it's slim pickings.
Turner was great, but needs to be playing at the club level weekly. Taking starts away from Slonina at this tournament (don't even get me started on Sean Johnson being the #2 at this tournament) to get him some extra match practice he won't get with his club team shouldn't be happening. Only is because our goalkeepers insist on being backups for great clubs or starting at mediocre clubs. On this path, Turner will fall the way of Steffen. Neal was very good too. He'll be a National Team center-back soon. Cowell has the potential, but needs more time. Reynolds is close, but still behind Scally and Dest on the right side. Sands is right there as a defensive midfielder back-up for Adams. Vazquez and Ferreira can only remain in the picture if they move to better leagues, but didn't hurt their chances going forward with their performances. I don't mind Jones or Mihailovic either, but they are kind of a little far down the depth chart.
On the bad side, Robinson was pretty bad, considering the competition at this tournament. He's falling down the CB charts. He needs that move to Europe badly, which might not go well. We have to be honest about that. His whole reputation has been built within MLS and against weak international competition. Tolkin showed he's not ready. He's young though, so he has time. I don't need to see any more of Zendejas. Doesn't do the job required. Aidan Morris was bad too, but it seems like there might've been a personal issue that could've contributed to it. Maybe you give him a slight pass, but it doesn't help him move up the depth chart for the Adams back-up. I can't take Busio's inclusion seriously when he's a back up in Serie B. He was middling in this tournament, but he's not a serious National Team contender until his club situation rectifies, if it ever does. The rest of the guys disqualify themselves.