I think McLeod is worse, especially at skating. I consider Talbot a decent 4th liner. I'm sure he would look better if he wasn't surrounded by AHLers so often. He is overpaid. I DON'T think he is an elite PKer, or even good on the PK. Mediocre at best.
I hated the trade since I love Downie, and I really don't think Talbot was the best Downie could get you at the time. I think it's just another one of those, Roy love a boarderline NHLer, for some reason. He liked Talbot. I like THE GUY, but his contract is ugly too. It's the same as the PAP thing, waive the guy rather than take an ugly contract back, or at least try it first. If they are so desperate to dump good players for whatever reason. Whatever though, it's all in the past.
Man, I couldn't view it any differently. I won't get into the McLeod debate since people see what they want to in him, but Talbot hasn't played with AHLers this year. Cody's spent pretty much the entire year on the 4th line and he has one more goal than Talbot who's played most of the year in the top 9, on all the lines, especially the last week or two where he was playing with Duchene and MacKinnon.
I definitely think he's an elite PKer though. Almost every kill he's on, he makes a great play. The whole PK unit took a 180 in the right direction when he came here, and it's been strong most of the year. He study's the other team's PP very well and anticipates the plays they like to make, and does a great job blocking the passing lanes, and then forcing the play to the boards where he can break up the play and get the puck out. I've never seen a player better at consistently getting the puck out along the half boards.
If only he could contribute something, just anything on the ice apart from this. It was absolutely maddening watching him playing with Dutchy and Mack, and blow scoring chances on literally every shift. If he's not whiffing on shots, or sending passes into someone's feet or behind them, he'll grab the puck in the offensive zone, lift his head up to look around, and you can just hear his inner monologue like it was on the PA going "duuuurrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr."