GDT: Game 23 - New York Rangers vs New Jersey Devils - 7pm EST, MSG

Status
Not open for further replies.

PuckLuck3043

Stairway To Heaven
Nov 15, 2017
9,926
14,955
Hudson Valley
I stand by my point that hiring Trotz would be a collassal overcorrection and overreaction.

"If success everywhere he goes" looks like this :
23 seasons.
1 Stanley Cup
9 missed playoffs
Only made ECF 2 other times, rest was 1st or 2nd round losses

Then success has a pretty low standard. To highlight, it took Ovechkin, Backstrom, Kusnetsov, Oshie and Carlson to win him a Stanley Cup in Washington. Hes either lost in the first 2 rounds or missed the playoffs in 20/23 seasons.

Thats a pretty low bar for success. Offense routinely suffers at the expense of defense under his system which bodes well for making playoffs but eventually runs thin when other teams start playing similar defense but find ways to score.

Our defense has now been atrocious under Quinn and Gallant and multiple different defensive assistant coaches. It may be a paying Trouba 8 million and using Hajek through multiple coaching regimes issue.

I for one and not on the Trotz train.
You make some good points but it's way more than just a player issue here. Trotz took over a very bad Nashville team and it took him a while to get them to the playoffs nearly every year. Since 09 his teams have made the playoffs 10 time in 13 years, including a Cup and those 2 ECF appearances with a slow and plodding Isles team. He also won 2 Jack Adams awards recently. The guy can coach. We need to do something.
 

McRanger92

Registered User
Jun 7, 2017
9,990
18,114
We have NMCs combined with high salaries and long terms. Trotz took mediocre teams without high paid star players and made them overperfom.

We have high paid star players that are underperforming. We just need them to perform as they should. We need a coach that is going to allow them to do that, not a coach that is going to kill the offense for expense of defense. It makes for regular season success but eventually when the other teams start playing similar styles they can stiffle Trotz teams limited offense while also scoring due to systematic tweaks that allow more offense.

Changing coaches is so you don't need to change all the players. Trotz with this roster still requires changing the makeup which A) defeats the purpose and B) we can't do because of the aforementioned NMCs

Trotz won a Cup with a team full of high paid underperforming stars
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad