Reality is 2-14-3. The roster is much better now then the past few years, but the results are not. Yes, I would have way more faith in DM sorting this out and way more faith in a vet coach like Tip then I do Chayka/Tocc. When any business gets this messy, experience is very valuable. Have either Chayka or Tocc gone through something like this and figured out how to fix it? We aren't the only team with injuries and they knew what they had in Loui, a borderline NHL goal tender, before the season started.
Was it a case of too much, too soon?
Assume that you are a player on the team in this offseason. The first thing that needs to be dealt with is Doan not returning and finding a replacement captain. That transition is already fairly interesting, but it probably means quite a bit to our team b/c of how much Doan meant and how few stable veterans we had. At this point, we hadn't added/subtracted players or coaches.
Then, we get the change up of a coach being out and within 48-96 hours of that happening, we changed up our entire team dynamic by adding some of those veterans.
Now, everyone is new, so there is not really a trusted voice to rely upon. The voices that we can rely upon ended he previous year injured (Richardson), still young (Domi), and/or away from the team (OEL).
Finally, we add a new coach that has the right message and ideas, but maybe that style didn't fit some of the additions that were made on this team.
I think that the lack of some measure of stability has brought us to a real crossroads, and that's what is making it tough to claw out of. Maybe this was where I was hoping that we could keep Tippett for one more year so that we could see exactly where this went. Yes, that may mean keeping Smith. Maybe Murphy gets dealt anyhow, and maybe we add Stepan as well, but not Raanta. If we were at this record with Tippett in charge, then I could agree with the idea that we needed to move on. I think we would have seen a team that is probably in the 11-15 point range right now. Speculation on my part, but there would have been just enough familiarity going forward that this adjustment wouldn't have as much difficulty. It probably still would have gotten Tip fired, as he wouldn't get us to the playoffs, and we would be a 75-84 point team. I think we would be more prepared on the defensive end for the future, though.