Not the biggest supporter of plus/minus in a vacuum, but Duclair's ability to not be a minus and hold a +12 over two seasons on a club that is a tire fire is pretty impressive to me. He also lit up the takeaways last year as I remember if someone wants to drudge that up.
But Tippett doesn't give him more minutes than Doan, so I'll assume he's terrible. Tippett, after all, has never seen a talented offensive player he wouldn't play that later blossomed with opportunity.
In fact, if we limit it just to Eriksson and Turris for high profile whiffs, is there another coach in the league that whiffed twice or more on high profile players? Probably lots of examples with one high profile miss. Any with two? Are we watching 3 and 4?