Absurdity
light switch connoisseur
- Jul 6, 2012
- 10,667
- 6,618
well we have the backup goalie now. all thats left is upgrade the D
If you could fix my miss-spelling of Smith's name, that would be great thanks.well we have the backup goalie now. all thats left is upgrade the D
Looks like we have our backup.
If you could fix my miss-spelling of Smith's name, that would be great thanks.
well we have the backup goalie now. all thats left is upgrade the D
Relying on the last P Bruin to give Rask a breather really didn't work out too well. Admittedly, I don't watch many Providence games at all. For those that do, do you think Smith a decent upgrade over Svedberg?
Smith outplayed Subban last year in AHL and is reliable in goal. Worth keeping around for that deal.
Not sure why we think this makes him the earmarked #2. McIntyre and Subban will fight it out for that spot. Smith is an excellent AHL goalie and worthy of a contract slot, but he will not beat out the kids.
Your memory is bad. He was fantastic in pre season. To me, he outplayed Svedberg but no way they could give him back up role with svedberg on 1 way deal. Sweeny played it smart this time around with a two way deal leaving more options open. Pretty clear he deserves a shot based on his play last season.IIRC, Smith didn't look particularly NHL-ready at the beginning of last year during the preseason games (the only time I've seen him play). But that's based on a very small sample size - 67 minutes and change in 3 of the 6 games where stats were recorded, with a 0.921 SV% - which, in retrospect, is pretty good (although you'd have to downgrade that for only playing about one period per game).
Wondering if my memory was bad, I found this from the preseason:
[NHL]2014010070-723-h
[/NHL]
I'm no goalie expert, but to me, that looks fairly soft. Also, note the score. Note the time.
All that said, looking at his numbers from Providence last year, he could be ready. He had his best year ever, and I'm gradually trusting Sweeney more and more with these decisions. I wouldn't mind upgrading the backup and/or getting some more competition in camp, but it's not a huge priority. I'm pretty sure Subban's not ready for the call. And I doubt McIntyre is.
Then again, according to board wisdom, I'm a horrible goalie judge. I actually thought Johnson was pretty damn good for us in 13-14, and was shocked when he took a nosedive with the Isles. Svedberg always made me poop my pants - he had that Jonathan Quick "athleticism" without the actual ability to make the save.