Proposal: FLO vs MTL

[Lockin17]

I would love to see Jonathan Huberdeau join the habs and see him play with Drouin and Domi.
The Panthers are dead last in the east and could use a big change by moving a player like Jonathan.

To Montreal :

Jonathan Huberdeau

To Florida :

Joel Armia
Nikita Sherback
Nick Suzuki ( future top 6 center )
2rd pick

What do you guy's think ?

Click to read more...

 

[ConnorMcMullet]

That offer would get beaten by every other team in the league.

 

[2022 Stanley Cup]

5rd pick

 

[Toronto makebeleifs]

A bottom 6 winger, a bust, a prospect, and a late pick for a guy that is finally hitting his stride and scoring 50+ pts a year... this isn't that great. Also; hubs plays as a winger, mtl still needs a natural center, no?

 

[Lockin17]

A bottom 6 winger, a bust, a prospect, and a late pick for a guy that is finally hitting his stride and scoring 50+ pts a year... this isn't that great. Also; hubs plays as a winger, mtl still needs a natural center, no?

Nahh we have Kok - Danault - Domi and Poelhing that will be playing next year.
And then Suzuki will be pushing for a center spot next year as well, i think we're good for now on center.

 

[Habs Halifax]

Florida would be looking for Suzuki and our 1st for JH. Not the type of deal the Habs should be making at this stage. Heck, Suzuki has the ability to be just as good as Huberdeau.

I like Huberdeau as well but so do the Panthers.

 

[izzy]

huberdeau who had 69 pts last year, ppg this year and 26 in 31 2 years ago

one of the most productive players in his position for that package??

 

[CanadienShark]

Huberdeau is worth much more.

 

[Lockin17]

Huberdeau is worth much more.

If you don't know who Nick Suzuki is you might say that,
this guy will be a great player for the next 15 years in this league , plus you have 2 decent players that can make the team this year and a 2rd pick , not too bad i think.
it's a similair trade that Patch got from Vegas.

 

[MintyFresh88]

If you don't know who Nick Suzuki you might say that,
this guy will be a great player for the next 15 years in this league , plus you have 2 decent players that can make the team this year and a 2rd pick , not too bad i think.
it's a similair trade that Patch got from Vegas.

Panthers have Barkov + Trocheck down the middle, explain to me why they would further weaken a position of need and add to a position of strength? The value isn't there to begin with, but this just makes it even more nonsensical.

Also, Pacioretty had a year left before UFA and he's 5 years older, not a great comparable.

 

[Just Linda]

This isn't the package that gets Huberdeau. Montreal wouldn't do the trade either, giving up Suzuki isn't in their plans nowadays.

What's Florida's needs?

 

[Hostile Offer]

A bottom 6 winger, a bust, a prospect, and a late pick for a guy that is finally hitting his stride and scoring 50+ pts a year... this isn't that great. Also; hubs plays as a winger, mtl still needs a natural center, no?

It isn't that great but you don't need to falsely call Scherbak a bust, a 2nd rounder a late pick and Suzuki nothing more than some prospect to get your point through.

 

[is the answer jesus]

If you don't know who Nick Suzuki is you might say that,
this guy will be a great player for the next 15 years in this league , plus you have 2 decent players that can make the team this year and a 2rd pick , not too bad i think.
it's a similair trade that Patch got from Vegas.

Huberdeau is a 25 year old 1st liner. Suzuki is a solid prospect, but he's proven jack shit at the NHL level. Also using the return on a 29 year old rental player as a comparision makes zero sense.

 

[Lockin17]

Huberdeau is a 25 year old 1st liner. Suzuki is a solid prospect, but he's proven jack **** at the NHL level. Also using the return on a 29 year old rental player as a comparision makes zero sense.

Patch was not a rental ? i don't know where you get that from.
The reason why the habs got that much for him is because he signed with Vegas on that trade , so he was not a rental.
And the 2 players only have 4 years difference, so yes my comparasion is not to bad.
And just so you know Huberdeau never hit 30 goals a year and Patch had 4 years of 30 goals +.

 

[TheImpatientPanther]

I would love to see Jonathan Huberdeau join the habs and see him play with Drouin and Domi.
The Panthers are dead last in the east and could use a big change by moving a player like Jonathan.

To Montreal :

Jonathan Huberdeau

To Florida :

Joel Armia
Nikita Sherback
Nick Suzuki ( future top 6 center )
2rd pick

What do you guy's think ?

Doesnt address any of our needs.

Borgstrom is more ready than Suzuki

Tippett and Noel are decent enough RW prospects that we dont need Armia or Scherbak.

Very easy no from FLA POV. Not saying Huberdeau isnt available, LW is our biggest current strength but he would be part of a trade to get us a top 4 RD.

This isn't the package that gets Huberdeau. Montreal wouldn't do the trade either, giving up Suzuki isn't in their plans nowadays.

What's Florida's needs?

A defensive top 4 RD

A starting goalie capable of 50+ games for the next 3-4 years while Montembeault develops in AHL.

 

[FLpanthers16]

If Huby was on the market half the league at minimum would be after him.

He has always been underrated and is a top notch winger.

 

[Captain Mountain]

I would love to see Jonathan Huberdeau join the habs and see him play with Drouin and Domi.
The Panthers are dead last in the east and could use a big change by moving a player like Jonathan.

To Montreal :

Jonathan Huberdeau

To Florida :

Joel Armia
Nikita Sherback
Nick Suzuki ( future top 6 center )
2rd pick

What do you guy's think ?

This doesn't address Florida's needs. It also doesn't address Montreal's needs. The only reason this any Habs fans would be interested is that he's a good player from Saint-Jerome. Montreal doesn't need more left-shot wingers.

 

[Just Linda]

Doesnt address any of our needs.

Borgstrom is more ready than Suzuki

Tippett and Noel are decent enough RW prospects that we dont need Armia or Scherbak.

Very easy no from FLA POV. Not saying Huberdeau isnt available, LW is our biggest current strength but he would part of a trade to get us a top 4 RD.




A defensive top 4 RD

A starting goalie capable of 50+ games for the next 3-4 years while Montembeault develops in AHL.

Perhaps Montreal is a good trading partner, Montreal's position of strength is RD.

Petry + Hudon for Huberdeau

 

[is the answer jesus]

Patch was not a rental ? i don't know where you get that from.
The reason why the habs got that much for him is because he signed with Vegas on that trade , so he was not a rental.
And the 2 players only have 4 years difference, so yes my comparasion is not to bad.
And just so you know Huberdeau never hit 30 goals a year and Patch had 4 years of 30 goals +.

He was a rental. He was in the last year of his deal. Now obviously Vegas had had some discussions with Pacioretty's camp pre-trade to see if he'd extend there. Which did help the return Montreal got. I'm well aware that Pacioretty can score goals, I'm also aware that he'll be on the wrong side of 30 once his extension kicks in and he had a terrible season last year that seems to be extending into this season. It's very reasonable to start wondering if Vegas made a huge mistake paying for what Pacioretty used to be and not what he currently is as a player. Again Huberdeau had 69 points last year. He's 25 years old and locked up in a reasonable long-term deal. Your offer isn't even close.

 

[TheImpatientPanther]

Perhaps Montreal is a good trading partner, Montreal's position of strength is RD.

Petry + Hudon for Huberdeau

Petry could be part of the trade but Hudon is of no interest to us at all so unless it becomes a bigger plus than Hudon, I don't think we're going to get anything done.

Huberdeau is 25 years old with a good contract and looks to be onto another 65 to 70pt season.

74 goals, 218pts in his last 279 games. (.78 pts per game) over the last 3.5 years. He was injured for half/most of the 2016-17 year.

 

[Toronto makebeleifs]

It isn't that great but you don't need to falsely call Scherbak a bust, a 2nd rounder a late pick and Suzuki nothing more than some prospect to get your point through.

Prospects are speculative, while Suzuki looks good there are plenty of junior players who's game doesn't translate to the show. He could be Joe sackic or Rob shremp. Won't know till he's put to the test. I used to be high on scherbak, I call him a bust because a guy with that amount of skill should be able to be more than a ahl/ nhl tweener.

 

[Mogo]

Aint happening. Huby has a great contract too.

Gimme signed Panarin

 

[smack66]

might need to add an additional 7th round pick to make this happen

 

[BatVader]

Seems like a lot from Montreal..... Panthers should throw in Ekblad to even it out a bit!

 

[Baksfamous112]

Petry could be part of the trade but Hudon is of no interest to us at all so unless it becomes a bigger plus than Hudon, I don't think we're going to get anything done.

Huberdeau is 25 years old with a good contract and looks to be onto another 65 to 70pt season.

74 goals, 218pts in his last 279 games. (.78 pts per game) over the last 3.5 years. He was injured for half/most of the 2016-17 year.

I’m interested. What else would we need to add to Petry?

I’m thinking maybe Lehkonen with another roster player coming back from FLA?