Lucic is an NHLer currently for the same reason Reaves, Deslaurieris etc are in the NHL. Their roles aren’t to put up points or be a magician with a puck on their stick, everytime you see a D-man turn the puck over to our F2 when Lucic is skating in on the forecheck or everytime you see a scrum end extremely quickly is his role. It’s a fair opinion to consider that a useless role in today’s game, but that’s why those players are still around.
But honestly what do you think hurts the team more, a 4th liner not doing good in their 4th line role, or a top 6er not doing good in their role? Secondly, would you rather see Pelletier play out the season getting 10 minutes a night and never see Lucic again, or see Pelletier sit a game or two and play in the top 6 when he isn’t? Because that’s what your original argument basically breaks down too.