Murray's awful netminding ended up being the difference, .
? Which goal was awful?
Mangiapane goal - deflection; no chance
Czarnik goal - great perfectly placed snipe that also bounced a bit weirdly
Frolik goal - deflection caused the rebound
Hamonic goal - deflection or it doesn't go in
Bennett goal - cross ice pass from Ryan, Bennett with nice hands to pull it past Murray.
Murray might look at the tape of that game and not flop on the Bennett goal the way he did, but it was a gamble he took to take away the pass. That gamble IMO happened because he (rightfully) didn't trust he defenseman to stop the pass across the slot. Maybe he saves that if he stays in his net or maybe Bennett finds a different hole.
Pitt might have their D to blame but not their goalie.