Dream scrap - 2 players any era

[Central Scrutinizer]

Maxime Lapierre vs wet paper bag.

 

[CaliforniaSeal]

Lemieux had six inches and forty-five pounds on Orr. Orr would be outmatched physically.

Bobby Orr beat the snot out of Pete Mahovalich who had 6 inches and 40 pounds on Orr. Orr was tough. Just ask Keith Magnuson (before he died)

 

[Lunatik*]

Ron Hextall vs. Ray Emery

 

[04' hockey]

Don't try to talk your way out of it. Your boy got his ass kicked.

Fotiu rarely fought compared to other tough guys because most guys were afraid of him.

If you don't believe me read Dave Schultz' book. He was scared to death of Fotiu and wouldn't come near him. At least Wilson and Holmgren had enough guts to have Fotiu beat the crap out of them.

Naahh.....THIS is an ass kicking

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6C3HmPoI8xs&feature=related

Word was back in the day Nicky FEARED Jethro..... "gentle Behn" didn't

 

[stallion19]

Martin St.Louis vs Theo Fleury

 

[pld459666]

In their Primes

Behn Wilson - Bob Probert

Stan Jonathan - Tie Domi

Chris Nilan - Rick Rypien

George McPhee - Rick Rypien

Troy Crowder - Derek Boogaard

Colton Orr - Joey Kocur (someone is getting KTFO)

 

[thinkinfeller]

Yeah, but he would need the "coke" to stay in that fight.

Bet if he were still alive you wouldn't say that to his face.

I had the chance to have a couple of beers with Bob 3 or 4 years ago, after an Oldtimers game. I asked him who he thought the toughest guy in the league was, and he said McGratton and Boogaard.

Probert was the first "heavyweight" I remember watching in the 80's, and he was a class act in person. Although fighting in hockey has evolved and the players have gotten bigger, I believe Probert (in his prime) could have gone toe to toe with anyone in today's NHL.

 

[Vilgrain Headache]

el removo...

 

[Vilgrain Headache]

based on the potential photographic hilarity, the answer is easy...

olli jokinen vs anybody

 

[Habstract]

Laraque vs Avery !!

 

[Jedrik]

Dave Brown vs Donald Brashear

Gino Odjick vs Bob Probert

Link Gaetz vs Derek Boogaard

My God, there's a name I heven't heard in a long time. Dude was a pretty scary s.o.b. I remember.

Matt Barnaby vs Sean Avery

Barnaby would clean him. Would be funny, though.

I agree. I think Kordic wins also, but couldn't think of a better pairing for him against a current player. So back to you.... who would you pit Kordic against in a dream scrap (no Jay Miller or Bob Probert)?

Kordic v. Lucic would be interesting.

 

[Jedrik]

I'd like to see Cam Neely vs Brendan Shanahan.

That must've happened, no?

 

[Jedrik]

Maxime Lapierre vs wet paper bag.

Wet Bag Hospitalizes Man.

 

[nevermore]

St. Louis vs B. Richards

 

[name]

That must've happened, no?

No.

Iginla vs Howe

 

[Killahpunk]

Eric Godard vs. Deryk Engelland

 

[Jedrik]

No.

Surprising, since there's like eight years of overlap on their playing careers, and they both played in the East (or Wales) during almost half of those. Very similar type players.

 

[Mr Atoz*]

Naahh.....THIS is an ass kicking

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6C3HmPoI8xs&feature=related

Word was back in the day Nicky FEARED Jethro..... "gentle Behn" didn't

The word form "who'? Your imagination?

Fotiu beat Wilson ass and never ran away from anyone.

 

[JABEE]

Rick Tocchet vs. Scott Stevens
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yZLUp5li_Qk

 

[Your Boy Troy]

Eric Lindros vs. Milan Lucic
Rick Tocchet vs. Wayne Simmonds
Joey Kocur vs. Luke Gazdic
P.J. Stock vs. Brett Gallant
Marty McSorley vs. Brian McGrattan
Tony Twist vs. Ryan Reaves
Rob Ray vs. Anthony Peluso
Dave Brown vs Patrick Bordeleau
Bob Probert vs. Deryk Engelland
Chris Simon vs. Jay Rosehill
Eric Cairns vs. Matt Carkner
Tie Domi vs. Pierre-Luc Leblond

 

[c-carp]

Bob Probert v Gord Gallant
Bob Probert v John Furguson
Stan Jonathan v Dennis Bonvie
Link Gaetz v Steve Durbano
Brett Gallant v Stan Jonathan
Jon Mirasty v PJ Stock
Dave Brown v Dave Schultz
Tony Twist v Behn Wilson
Rick Rypien v Todd Gill
Terry O Rielly v Colton Orr
Bob Gassoff v Bob Probert
Tie Domi v Stan Jonathan

 

[Constable]

george parros vs paul bissonette

2 personalities duel

 

[David Bruce Banner]

Lindros / Howe

 

[Sparksrus3]

Dan cloutier. Vs. Ray emery
Chris nilan vs lucic
Tocchet vs simmonds
Bobby nystrom vs simmonds
Laraque vs gillies
Joey Kocur vs Gordie Howe
Gretzky vs Lemieux
Vukota vs matt Martin

 

[c-carp]

Bob Probert and Rick Rypien.

Would put the phrase "Pound for Pound" on a whole new level of awesome.

Rypien wouldn't want any of Probie, that would be similar to Probie v Al Stewart. Rypien was a tough as nails but in Probie he is messing w a next level guy. Rypien w a guy like Todd Gill would have been awesome