No I don't agree... if you told me we scored 0 goals, but also kept the other team off the scoreboard, I'd as we come away with 2 points more often than not... especially against a team like NJ. Unfortunately Holtby can't seem to keep the other team off the scoreboard.
This is the thing here. The situation matters. Nobody's scoring and it's a choppy game likely headed to OT and maybe the SO. It's both teams playing for 1-2 points, and NJ has been horrid at getting that second point. So all you have to do is stand pat like the other team for 10 more minutes.
But instead Holtby gags again when it counts most, and the result is a 3-4 point turnaround in the standings, depending on whether the Caps could have gotten lucky in the last half of the third. As it was it ended up being a 3 point turnaround as the Caps lose a point they should have had while NJ picks up 2 (Caps now down 1 point in the standings to NJ instead of up 2).
Yeah yeah, it's November. But November points count the same as March and April points. And how badly were we fighting for every single point last Spring? These are big points and the kind of things that get goaltenders shipped out of town after they happen in a playoff race. Holtby had better cure the Choke-itis before then or he may be backing someone up, maybe elsewhere.
I feel like we're overreacting to one game.
It'd be interesting to see the mood change if we win tonight.
"Blow up the whole team" is an overreaction to one game but I don't think this is about one game. And yes if they win there will be more optimism because that's how people and sports are. How a team is trending affects your outlook. Nothing sinister or head-shaking about that.
Looks to me like they didnt score a goal in a game where they might have
scored several and gave up only one goal in a game where they might have
given up none.
How many chances did NJ have, but fail to convert? I'm sure their fans could say the same things. Why stop the what if game at one goal? What if the Caps scored 7 goals? Then Holtby's error doesn't matter. But they didn't, and it did. That's the type of game it was. A goaltender has to recognize when he's in a lockdown situation like that, and he has to button up his game.
You can bet the players are aware of when a game is a free-flowing shootout vs a tight grinding hackfest. Niskanen even talked about it post-game, and clearly bit his tongue talking about the goal. Instead he dutifully and politically went on about how tight the game was, how they needed to capitalize on early chances and the old fallback of "luck" (in order to avoid throwing his goaltender under the bus to the press).
Trotz plays a system where his lines are constructed for balance and his forwards forecheck aggressively while d-men activate often. There isn't a foot on the gas pedal firewagon aspect to it so much as a pressure aspect. Four lines roll and time once it's time to change you'd better change, so little opportunity to make open ice runs at the end of shifts. Better dump and change and have fresh legs add the next wave of pressure. Then go to the net, and shoot often. Hope to get lucky. Once you have the lead you protect it by tying up the puck and getting it deep.
This all means your goaltending has got to be at a certain, high level or else you will get burned by counter-attacks and open ice plays. That's exactly what we've seen, especially when other teams surge out of desperation. Little mistakes by your netminder will cost you dearly.
Last year we chalked it up to some wobbly goaltending due to Oates' interference as well as his baffling, passive system that funneled shots at the goaltender. This year we're blocking shots again and pushing the play up ice more but still not getting the key saves.
You would hope that a guy like Korn could right the ship there but so far the results are spotty. Some have said that d-men and goaltenders take longer to develop, and that may be true in some cases. But it doesn't mean ALL young goaltenders and d-men improve as they get older. Some flash early and then fizzle out. Rare is the player who bursts onto the league with star potential, falters for a few years, and then returns to star status.
Which one is Holtby?