Playing Sprong with Malkin and Kessel would be the smart thing to do, which is why it will NOT be happening.
I'd play Phil with Sid and Jake. I know, Sid likes playing with Phil even less than he likes playing with Horny, but we've tried everything else with Sid, including giving ******* Reaves more looks with him.
And, let's also be honest . . . we don't have a LW on the roster or in the organization to crystallize Geno and Phil, two great players, into a great line.
My lines . . .
Jake-Sid-Phil
Hags-Geno-Sprong
Sheary-Sheahan-Horny
I'd flip the L1 and L3 wingers, and you've got it.
How the hell does it help anything just to throw Sprong into the bottom six. Seize the opportunity to mix up the top six.
All those times Phil is getting the puck from Geno and not shooting . . . Sprong will be selfish, and that's a good thing right now. And, stylistically, Sprong is a better match with Geno than Phil is. Not a better player, a better match.
And, as I said, everything else has been tried with Sid . . . give him a game with Jake-Phil. Maybe it works, maybe it doesn't, but it's sure as hell better than throwing the same **** against the wall every night.