Proposal: (DAL-COL): Barrie+4th Round Pick for 2017 3OA+2nd Round Pick

[Former Ladder]

+2017 3rd Overall Pick
+2017 2nd Round Pick (39th Overall)


+Tyson Barrie
+2017 4th Round Pick (94th Overall)/2018 3rd Round Pick [Avs do not own a 2017 3rd Round Pick]


The Stars get an established top 4 defenseman that has shown he is capable of putting 50+ points on the Avs and is a good PP QB.

The Avs get another high draft pick to keep building up their prospect pool and advance their rebuild.

Exchange of picks is to even out getting an established player for a draft pick.

Click to read more...

 

[c_robio]

Dallas needs LD

 

[AvsGuy]

I feel like Dallas already has a Barrie in Klingberg

 

[Former Ladder]

Dallas needs LD

Barrie's game works on both sides. While he shoots RH, he can play LD.

 

[JoemAvs]

+2017 3rd Overall Pick
+2017 2nd Round Pick (39th Overall)


+Tyson Barrie
+2017 4th Round Pick (94th Overall)/2018 3rd Round Pick [Avs do not own a 2017 3rd Round Pick]


The Stars get an established top 4 defenseman that has shown he is capable of putting 50+ points on the Avs and is a good PP QB.

The Avs get another high draft pick to keep building up their prospect pool and advance their rebuild.

Exchange of picks is to even out getting an established player for a draft pick.

I really don't see Dallas needing Barrie.

Them jumping us was basically worst case. They need the exact same things we do and are in our division..

Value is close enough but I think this doesn't make much sense for the Stars and not really all that much for the Avs either unless they already have something lined up for Duchene or Landeskog as well...

 

[howkie]

Honka and Klingberg should make Barrie not that intressting...

 

[masinaLFC]

nope

 

[Oberyn]

Barrie's game works on both sides. While he shoots RH, he can play LD.

Has he ever played LD on the Avs?

Regardless, I don't see why Stars do this. Barrie isn't the type of defenseman they should be targeting and the value isn't great for them.

 

[Muffin]

Has he ever played LD on the Avs?

Regardless, I don't see why Stars do this. Barrie isn't the type of defenseman they should be targeting and the value isn't great for them.

He plays LD with Johnson when the Avs desperately need a goal.

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

Barrie is RD and Dallas needs LD period, Pretty sure Dallas can do better for the #3 pick then Barrie.

 

[Satan]

Barrie would be redundant on Dallas.

Not interested in him at that price anyway.

 

[WhatWhat]

Dallas has a better Barrie in Klingberg and a you Barrie in the making in Honka. He is beyond redundant in Dallas

 

[cgf]

I'd hate to face Tyson 6 times a year with that team around him. He'd start putting up video game #s if they just let him loose; easily see him in the 60s with that kind of a PP to leech points off of.

 

[Mr Misty]

i'd hate to face tyson 6 times a year with that team around him. He'd start putting up video game #s if they just let him loose; easily see him in the 60s with that kind of a pp to leech points off of.

17.6%

 

[Weast]

17.6%

Yeah but
Benn-Seguin-Spezza
Klingberg-Barrie
Will be pummelling pucks in the back of the net

 

[Mr Misty]

Yeah but
Benn-Seguin-Spezza
Klingberg-Barrie
Will be pummelling pucks in the back of the net

Nope, Curt Fraser.

 

[trentmccleary]

+2017 3rd Overall Pick
+2017 2nd Round Pick (39th Overall)


+Tyson Barrie
+2017 4th Round Pick (94th Overall)/2018 3rd Round Pick [Avs do not own a 2017 3rd Round Pick]


The Stars get an established top 4 defenseman that has shown he is capable of putting 50+ points on the Avs and is a good PP QB.

The Avs get another high draft pick to keep building up their prospect pool and advance their rebuild.

Exchange of picks is to even out getting an established player for a draft pick.

I can't imagine Barrie and the 4th rounder bringing back the 3rd overall on it's own. This deal looks more than a little one-sided.

 

[glovesave_35]

Even more than handedness, the issue here is style of play. Barrie is too much like Klingberg, and Klingberg is both better and cheaper.

I will say that having both would be an embarrassment of riches in terms of offense from D and the PP with both could/should be lethal.

 

[oilers4life5]

What would Dallas pay for Griffin R? We are going to lose him in expansion.

 

[Tripod]

What would Dallas pay for Griffin R? We are going to lose him in expansion.

Snickers.










No really, a Snickers bar.

 

[The Madrigal]

Value is way off. Tyson Barrie is worth about half of that.

 

[Tysonson3]

Value is way off. Tyson Barrie is worth about half of that.

Ha! No Tyson Barrie is probably worth around the 3rd overall pick. Especially given the quality of players available at that pick

 

[Avs44]

Value is way off. Tyson Barrie is worth about half of that.

In this draft? Yeah, no.

 

[Kelly]

Barrie is not worth the 3rd overall pick.

 

[Kcb12345]

In this draft? Yeah, no.

This draft has several players who can be better than Barrie eventually, and probably will be better than him.