Compare Shane Doan with Clark Gillies

[MXD]

So Franzen would be an HOFer?

fighting is not legal, that's why both players go to the box after a fight. it shouldn't be rewarded.

the argument was that Gillies was an important part of the Isles' dynasty. but again, you could say that Kris Draper was very useful to the Wings from 1997-2008, in a shutdown role. but he's no HHOF material either.

I think you don't get it.

When you're so good at fighting that.... you don't have to fight. I think that's a plus for your team, and the game in general. Especially if you can score 30 goals a year.