combine 2018 and 2019 draft, top ten

[maplepred]

If you had to merge this draft with the past draft, what would your top ten look like?
Trying to compare the two.

Thanks in advance,

Click to read more...

 

[maplepred]

Let me be the first to give it a shot. (No QB’s)

1. Nick Bosa
2. Quinnen Williams
3. Saquon Barkley
4. Bradley Chubb
5. Josh Allen
6. Quenton Nelson
7. Derwin James
8. Roquan Smith
9. Ed Oliver
10. Devin White

What do you think??

 

[Unholy Diver]

Why no QB's? That was a big part of last years top 10 and likely will be part of this years as well

 

[maplepred]

Why no QB's? That was a big part of last years top 10 and likely will be part of this years as well

You are more than welcome to do a list with QB's included. I would look forward to seeing the rankings. Hoping others put their top ten up as well.

 

[m9]

I'm going to go off my rankings at the time of each draft as opposed to looking at it with the new information from last season.

1. Sam Darnold
2. Josh Rosen
3. Baker Mayfield
4. Kyler Murray
5. Dwayne Haskins
6. Quinnen Williams
7. Nick Bosa
8. Bradley Chubb
9. Roquan Smith
10. Quenton Nelson

 

[rangerssharks414]

I haven't followed the draft at all this year. All I know is that I had Rosen as the #1 QB on my "board" last year. Yuck.

If I did make a list, I wouldn't have any biases towards the 2018 rookies that played last year.

 

[maplepred]

I'm going to go off my rankings at the time of each draft as opposed to looking at it with the new information from last season.

1. Sam Darnold
2. Josh Rosen
3. Baker Mayfield
4. Kyler Murray
5. Dwayne Haskins
6. Quinnen Williams
7. Nick Bosa
8. Bradley Chubb
9. Roquan Smith
10. Quenton Nelson

Nice list but I would have josh Allen almost tied with Chubb. Williams higher as well.

 

[m9]

Nice list but I would have josh Allen almost tied with Chubb. Williams higher as well.

I just really value QB's that have a good chance at being long-term starters more than any other positions.

Allen & Devin White were the next two guys I had down.

 

[maplepred]

I just really value QB's that have a good chance at being long-term starters more than any other positions.

Allen & Devin White were the next two guys I had down.

Fair enough. I guess that’s why I was originally hoping to see some lists without QBs. They always seem to be so highly ranked. Would you do a list minus QBs?

 

[m9]

Fair enough. I guess that’s why I was originally hoping to see some lists without QBs. They always seem to be so highly ranked. Would you do a list minus QBs?

1. Q Williams
2. N Bosa
3. B Chubb
4. R Smith
5. Q Nelson
6. D White
7. Josh Allen
8. Derwin James
9. Saquon Barkley
10. Tremaine Edmunds
Close: Oliver, Gary, Dillard

I will say that after the top 2 guys, the other 11 are extremely close.

 

[maplepred]

1. Q Williams
2. N Bosa
3. B Chubb
4. R Smith
5. Q Nelson
6. D White
7. Josh Allen
8. Derwin James
9. Saquon Barkley
10. Tremaine Edmunds
Close: Oliver, Gary, Dillard

I will say that after the top 2 guys, the other 11 are extremely close.

Nice list! I dig it!

I still can’t figure out why so many mocks have Allen and boss going before Quinnen Williams. Why?!?!

 

[m9]

Nice list! I dig it!

I still can’t figure out why so many mocks have Allen and boss going before Quinnen Williams. Why?!?!

The teams near the top of the draft have a bigger need at edge rusher than DT.

Also - those players are good too.

 

[maplepred]

The teams near the top of the draft have a bigger need at edge rusher than DT.

Also - those players are good too.

I would think the niners and jets could go either way. Is it that defensive end is just a more valuable position?

 

[m9]

I would think the niners and jets could go either way. Is it that defensive end is just a more valuable position?

I would just say that pass rush in general is more valued and not really DT v DE.

Some old school guys will value pass rush from the DT more because it's closer and a quicker line to the QB.

There are just so many DT/edge prospects this year that there will be a ton of different rankings out there.

 

[DaaaaB's]

1. Q Williams
2. N Bosa
3. B Chubb
4. R Smith
5. Q Nelson
6. D White
7. Josh Allen
8. Derwin James
9. Saquon Barkley
10. Tremaine Edmunds
Close: Oliver, Gary, Dillard

I will say that after the top 2 guys, the other 11 are extremely close.

This would pretty much be my non QB list but I'd take out Gary/Dillard and replace them with Minkah Fitzpatrick and Jeffery Simmons. My top 15 would be rounded out by Hockenson and either Vita Vea or Denzel Ward. I like Dillard a lot too tho. I think Gary could be a bust but he does have major potential.

 

[m9]

This would pretty much be my non QB list but I'd take out Gary/Dillard and replace them with Minkah Fitzpatrick and Jeffery Simmons. My top 15 would be rounded out by Hockenson and either Vita Vea or Denzel Ward. I like Dillard a lot too tho. I think Gary could be a bust but he does have major potential.

Hockenson and Ward were borderline for me. Vea was a fair amount lower for me last year.

 

[maplepred]

Anyone else have a list?