To dig up a meme from 8 or so years ago - LEAVE CHARA ALONE!
Seriously. Dude gets a freak injury at the start of the season - I Zaprudered the hell out of that clip and couldn't see the obvious injury. Anyone other player, and I'd wonder about needing to put that player in bubble wrap, but Chara's conditioning is bar-none the best in the league. (Okay, those pull-ups this year were suspect, but come ON.)
The problem was that we have no plan going forward. Yes, he's great. But he's NOT going to always be the #1 D, and we needed to start planning and adjusting for that last year. According to Chiarelli, that plan included cap dumping Boychuk. Combine that with multiple injuries to virtually everyone in front of Rask (Miller x2, Krug's uncalled thumb slash with an AWFUL Twitter pic, Hamilton's season ender), and you're asking too much of even the superhuman that is Chara.
So, back off, Internet. No, we don't have the Chara of 2010-1. Yes, for his current cap hit, he's not a bargain - but we're paying for the Chara of 2011, and there's definitely some ketchup in the bottle - you just gotta thump it where it says "33 varieties", and it'll come out.