DFF
Registered User
- Feb 28, 2002
- 22,316
- 6,567
CGY's 4 vs WPG's 4
- Thread starter Legend123
- Start date
DFF
Registered User
- Feb 28, 2002
- 22,316
- 6,567
yes, arguably...and it's not last year anymore. Scheifele I can understand....Wheeler no
Flames but it's basically a coin flip. Tkachuk is the real difference to me.
Alot also depends on how one feels about Laine and he has his issues right now.
Alot also depends on how one feels about Laine and he has his issues right now.
"Its not last year" last year speaks volumes tho. Yeah the flames are hot, it the jets are still counting their success arent they. And they're still not even their final form.
7even
Offered and lost
- Jan 9, 2009
- 15,675
- 10,233
- Jan 9, 2009
- 15,675
- 10,233
WINNIPEG
Forwards
Wheeler (32) 1.30 pts/gp
Scheifele (25) 1.25 pts/gp
Connor (22) .77 pts/gp
Laine (20).73 pts/gp
Ehlers (22) .68 pts/gp
Defense
Byfuglien (33) .90 pts/gp
Morrissey (23) .60 pts/gp
CALGARY
Forwards
Gaudreau (25) 1.46 pts/gp
Monahan (24) 1.20 pts/gp
Lindholm (24) 1.13 pts/gp
Tkachuk (21) 1.13 pts/gp
Backlund (29) .55 pts/gp
Defense
Giordano (35) 1.00 pts/gp
Hanifin (21) .50 pts/gp
Forwards
Wheeler (32) 1.30 pts/gp
Scheifele (25) 1.25 pts/gp
Connor (22) .77 pts/gp
Laine (20).73 pts/gp
Ehlers (22) .68 pts/gp
Defense
Byfuglien (33) .90 pts/gp
Morrissey (23) .60 pts/gp
CALGARY
Forwards
Gaudreau (25) 1.46 pts/gp
Monahan (24) 1.20 pts/gp
Lindholm (24) 1.13 pts/gp
Tkachuk (21) 1.13 pts/gp
Backlund (29) .55 pts/gp
Defense
Giordano (35) 1.00 pts/gp
Hanifin (21) .50 pts/gp
Last edited:
Duffalufagus
Registered User
- Jan 4, 2017
- 1,680
- 980
The Big M
Registered User
- Dec 29, 2017
- 187
- 442
The ages here are important. If you notice Tkachuk is only 21 and can still get better!?
But then Laine is only 20. Connor and Ehlers are only 22.
All of them have a lot of room to grow as NHLer's and will.
Therefore, Jets have the best group going "forward".
- Jan 9, 2009
- 15,675
- 10,233
But then Wheeler, their top producer is 32 whereas the Flames top producer is only 25 and the Flames top player is significantly better than the Jets top player.
Hyperbole
Johnny g is not sigifnciantly better than scheifele or wheeler
Scheifele plays center. Wheeler plays a bigger body game
Ya... Gaudreau is only 10 points up on Wheeler and 12 on Schiefele who is tied with Monahan.
After that, Tkachuk is far better than Laine at hockey. Im sure Laine cab floss better though.
Lindholm way better than Ehlers as well.
Johnny Hoxville
The Return of a Legend
This is how I see it.
Scheifele > Monahan (Mony has really closed the gap)
Gaudreau > Ehlers
Tkachuk = Laine
Lindholm > Connor
Flames by a hair. Can’t blame anyone for picking either.
Scheifele > Monahan (Mony has really closed the gap)
Gaudreau > Ehlers
Tkachuk = Laine
Lindholm > Connor
Flames by a hair. Can’t blame anyone for picking either.
- Jan 9, 2009
- 15,675
- 10,233
Hyperbole? I don't think you know the definition of the word.
By the end of the season Gaudreau will have scored 20 pts more than Wheeler and Scheifele. I'll take those 20 pts any day. And then you have Money who a clutch goal scorer that's deadly from the slot. Now we compare Tkachuk and Lindholm to Laine and Ehlers or Laine and Connor or Ehlers and Connor... Well there s no comparison. The Flames are clearly superior. The pts prove it. Your say so doesn't change the facts.
Dicdonya
Registered User
- Jul 21, 2011
- 4,441
- 2,588
Lol at anyone pretending Gaudreau, Scheifele, or Wheeler are significantly better then any of each other. They’re all great players, any difference is minimal, no matter who you put first amongst them.
Laine is clearly the issue here, if he’s a consistent league leading goal scorer I would take the Jets core moving forward, since he’s not yet and is struggling to do much while not scoring, I picked the group that is scoring more points overall and helping their team lead the conference in points.
Laine is clearly the issue here, if he’s a consistent league leading goal scorer I would take the Jets core moving forward, since he’s not yet and is struggling to do much while not scoring, I picked the group that is scoring more points overall and helping their team lead the conference in points.
I dont think you know what the word means
Scheifele has proven himself over the past 3 seasons to be the better player
Just because the flames are hot right now dont change what those 2 players have been doing the past 3 seasons
Make your silly arguments comparing player to player
Winnipeg has been inconsistent and hasn't looked as good as last year and yet they're still head to head with flames enough have things going right then atm
Sound like leafs fan right now just because the flames are finally doing well
This will probably be the best half season in all of those Flames players' careers except for Backlund and Hanifin
Last edited:
- Jan 9, 2009
- 15,675
- 10,233
Ah... if only life in the past changed how you do in the present.. It doesn't work like that. Scoring 100 pts last year doesn't have a hill of beans to do with scoring this year. Ask James Neal.
The past is just memories.. The present is what counts now. Ask Oiler fans.
As to the Jets being equal with Flames this year, am I missing something? Did the Flames not beat the Jets 6-3 in one game and 4-1 in the other in the two meetings this year? Doesn't sound equal to me.
Last edited:
flamesforcup
Registered User
- Sep 5, 2017
- 3,026
- 3,539
out of the 2 teams Johnny g is the best player and Scheif/Wheeler are 2 and 3 in my opinion. Btw good poll op very close. I think Tkachuk tips it in the Flames favor.
flamesforcup
Registered User
- Sep 5, 2017
- 3,026
- 3,539
I'd give the edge to the Flames. Their guys have just a bit more well rounded games so far though they are mostly older and more physically developed. Jets could catch up in time.
