Proposal: CGY/CBJ

[Wayne Primeau]

Here's an idea I've had. Let me know if it's any good.

To Calgary:

Alex Wennberg
Sonny Milano

To Columbus:

TJ Brodie
Andrew Mangiapane

Click to read more...

 

[DCDM]

Why?

 

[Wayne Primeau]

Why?

TJ Brodie's value is at its all-time highest and it's likely we'd lose him in the expansion draft anyway. The Flames could use some more help down the middle and Wennberg helps them out there. He's a pass-first centre who's a better distributor than Ryan.

 

[XLeafer]

why would CBJ even do this

 

[Tkachuky]

Not moving Brodie.

 

[Spazkat]

I thought CBJ was set on D? Aside from that I doubt they're ready to give up on Wennberg for a guy that'd be on their 3rd pairing

 

[DFF]

Here's an idea I've had. Let me know if it's any good.

To Calgary:

Alex Wennberg
Sonny Milano

To Columbus:

TJ Brodie
Andrew Mangiapane

You dont like the season so far?

This is stupid for the Flames to trade their better dman for secondary help which they dont need

 

[Viqsi]

This might be considered if perchance we do something like trading Werenski for a much better C. Even then, it's extraordinarily dubious. As is, zero chance. We need improvements at center and are more than set at LD.

(And no, you can't have him. Not unless you're willing to give us Monahan.)

 

[Bjornar Moxnes]

This might be considered if perchance we do something like trading Werenski for a much better C. Even then, it's extraordinarily dubious. As is, zero chance. We need improvements at center and are more than set at LD.

(And no, you can't have him. Not unless you're willing to give us Monahan.)

What ever happened to Savard? Just 2 seasons ago he was still putting up impressive metrics while being the go to shutdown player with Jack Johnson of all players.

 

[ESH]

No reason Calgary should do this.

Or Columbus really. They don’t need more defensemen do they?

 

[Viqsi]

What ever happened to Savard? Just 2 seasons ago he was still putting up impressive metrics while being the go to shutdown player with Jack Johnson of all players.

Nothing happened to Savard. He's our #2RD behind Jones.

He's having to cover for Werenski's growing pains right now, tho, so he may look a little dubious to statwatchers.

 

[Bjornar Moxnes]

Nothing happened to Savard. He's our #2RD behind Jones.

Maybe I should clarify. He's seemed to lost a major step since 2016-2017.

 

[Viqsi]

Maybe I should clarify. He's seemed to lost a major step since 2016-2017.

...yeah, I realized that half a second too late, and thought I could get a ninja edit in.

 

[Bjornar Moxnes]

This might be considered if perchance we do something like trading Werenski for a much better C. Even then, it's extraordinarily dubious. As is, zero chance. We need improvements at center and are more than set at LD.

(And no, you can't have him. Not unless you're willing to give us Monahan.)

I'm willing to give up Monahan and way more for Jones.

 

[Viqsi]

I'm willing to give up Monahan and way more for Jones.

Jones doesn't move for anything y'all own.

 

[Dr Quincy]

Here's an idea I've had. Let me know if it's any good.

To Calgary:

Alex Wennberg
Sonny Milano

To Columbus:

TJ Brodie
Andrew Mangiapane

Why does Columbus need a Dman?

 

[Crede777]

Columbus doesn’t need another D and I don’t think Calgary really needs more forwards.

 

[Flames Fanatic]

Pass.

 

[CaptainCrunch67]

Calgary says no, not with the way the season is going so far and ripping a massive hole in their blueline would be incredibly dumb. Plus those two players wouldn't move the needle at all for Brodie

 

[major major]

Brodie isn't a fit in Columbus, not unless Giordano is coming to help him.

Wennberg and Milano are available but that wouldn't be the return.

 

[3074326]

If Columbus were to move a Dman for a center, this would make a lot of sense. Until then, not sure it works.

 

[Some Other Flame]

What is with CP Flames fans being obsessed with trading Brodie? He's showing the last two years were clearly the fault of a craptacular coach and not because he just fell off a cliff. He and Giordano have fantastic chemistry, why break that up and especially for such a lackluster deal?

And the expansion draft is like 3 years away. Why cripple the current windows over fears from something so far away?

 

[CraigsList]

Why would both teams mess with their success and chemistry?

No thanks.

 

[Noisia]

No thanks as a Flames fan.

 

[JohnnyJacket13]

Only way I'd consider this is if there would be a follow up move to acquire a top-line center with Werenski as part of that deal. Too many left shot defensemen as-is, and there would be a significant hole at center if Wennberg is traded without a suitable upgrade at the position coming back in return.

Also don't really see why Calgary would want to trade Brodie