Jarmo is incapable of picking up a Dman who turns out better than a 7D.
schultz
connauton
leopold
falk
quincey
chorney
Lol
Since, you want to nitpick and include low level trades and waiver wire pickups...
Jarmo also traded for Seth Jones. He drafted Zach Werenski in the 1st round. Markus Nutivaara was drafted in the 7th round... Shoot, Gabriel Carlsson and Vladislav Gavrikov could become everyday NHL'ers in the next 2 years as well and they were drafted just 2.5 years ago...
mean, what do we expect out of a waiver wire pickup or trading just a 5th round pick for a player? Your not going to get too many solid every day D-men for the next 4 years from a waiver wire claim or trading a 5th round pick for a player that is about 34 years old...
But, Nick Schultz went on to play 2 more entire seasons of 80, 81 games for the Philadelphia Flyers in 2014-2015- So, that looks like he was a #6 D-man for that team in the next 2 years that he wasn't with us. Not bad.
Connauton was actually really hot for a while and a pretty valuable waiver wire pickup for us. I know many fans were surprised we got him off waivers- In 54 games in 2014-2015- He had 9 goals, 19 points, +1 rating. Next season, he played in 55 NHL games with us and Arizona (picked up off waivers), had 17 points. Granted, it's with Arizona- But, he has 12 points in 51 NHL games this season, so he's still getting Top 6 D-man playing time in the NHL still. He's played close to 200 NHL games in the last 4 years- Not bad for nothing more than a #7 D-man.
We acquired Kyle Quincey for Dalton Prout. Quincey was just slated to be a #7 D-man for us anyways, but we got rid of Prout for him. Prout's playing in the AHL now anyways.
What's the harm in picking up Taylor Chorney? He's signed for 825,000 this year alone and he'll be a UFA this off-season. We have Kukan, Nutivaara being out for at least the next month. You said just about a week or two ago that Ryan Murray was more fragile than the average NHL'er, his body can't handle the grind of the NHL, so heck we might as well prepare for him being injured anyways. Jack Johnson's a UFA this off-season, we might be able to obtain a forward or a 1st round draft pick, so he might be traded here in the next 4 days. You also mentioned that Ryan Murray and Zach Werenski to an extent lack "heart".. So, 2 top 6 D-men out for the next month.. Jack Johnson could be traded in 4 days- That sounds like we could be missing at least 3 D-men, 4 if Murray gets hurt with ZW who happens to lack heart..
So, let's dig into Cleveland- Brady Austin is just on AHL contract, 15 points in 50 games, has only played 5 NHL games in his career.. Gabriel Carlsson has been scratched the last 2 games and has been pretty much injured the last month, only able to play 2-3 games since coming back, probably can't at this point. Ryan Collins has 3 points in 33 games, -18 rating, I'll pass. Siebenaler- 6 points in 23 games this year, -6 rating, I'll also pass. Cameron Gaunce, at the age of nearly 28 has played in fewer NHL games in his career than his age- 27 games. I could understand Gaunce being a #7 up here in times of a pinch, but I'll take Taylor over him playing on the top 6 roster...
We're kind of in a bind right now. If you have better solutions, let us know.