I honestly believe that anyone on this board who can understand basic statistics would have approached the failure of the PP1 unit better than this coaching staff.
Getting Werenski off of the QB and PP1 unit is so simple that even a child could do it. But not the "professionals" coaching the CBJ. And the GM can't duck some responsibility for the failure of the PP to produce at a level needed to win at this level.
Yeah before the season there was talk about stealing what works, as in taking pieces of other successful teams playbooks and trying to implement them. I'd say this might be showing in the defensive zone and especially PK. But who is this PP from?
When you have the pieces the team currently has, identifying the main threats on PP should not be difficult at all. There's a league elite shooter with a right handed shot. Usually when you look at successful PP with a right handed main threat, there is a right handed defenseman who is capable of moving the puck quickly from right to left, and also is a shooting threat themselves. We have such defensemen, at least one in Boqvist and I also think Jiricek could run it better than any LHD.
It needs to start with allowing a RHD to feed Laine on the left. Marchenko is a good bumber spot for the RH setup, Boone or Vronk up front.
The question is then between Johnny and Fantilli on the right boards. If Johnny wants to run a PP from the left, then Fantilli should be in this spot and Johnny in the other PP running it from right and Zach on the point. Fantilli is also a bigger shooting threat himself than Johnny is, so I'd like him on the same PP as Laine. And if Johnny is on the left side on PP2, then the right side would be Chinny or KJ.
Why is it so difficult? At the end of the game with goalie pulled they had Laine on the left side again and it was generating better chances than the PP had all game.