Rich09
Registered User
- Oct 22, 2004
- 137
- 0
2003 10th pick Kostitsyn, 11 Jeff Carter... Does the Montreal Canadiens made a error there?
SportBoy said:2003 10th pick Kostitsyn, 11 Jeff Carter... Does the Montreal Canadiens made a error there?
Komisarek8 said:huge margin? why because he looked more dominant? Obviously, he's playing with sick players on the most dominant team in Junior History ...on the 2nd line..
Would Kostitsyn come close to ranking the goals and pts that Carter got if he was put in the same situation..I say probarbly..so you never know.
3rd- While Carter is a safer bet, Kost upside remains higher, with Chipchura in for the Habs, do they really need Carter that much or can they take a chanec on Kost?
I say go for the chance..
WAY TOO EARLY TO TELL...
Komisarek8 said:3rd- While Carter is a safer bet, Kost upside remains higher, with Chipchura in for the Habs, do they really need Carter that much or can they take a chanec on Kost?
I say go for the chance..
WAY TOO EARLY TO TELL...
McDonald19 said:At the time Montreal picked the most talented player available at #10.
But Carter keeps getting better and would be Montreal's choice now if they could redo that draft.
sonnytheman said:actually, it would probably be Bergeron. But if I had to pick today between Kostitsyn and Carter, it would be Carter, because I've seen him more and he's impressed each time I've seen him.
MojoJojo said:Kostytsin still has the talent of a First overall draft pick.
Komisarek8 said:huge margin? why because he looked more dominant? Obviously, he's playing with sick players on the most dominant team in Junior History ...on the 2nd line..
Would Kostitsyn come close to ranking the goals and pts that Carter got if he was put in the same situation..I say probarbly..so you never know.
3rd- While Carter is a safer bet, Kost upside remains higher, with Chipchura in for the Habs, do they really need Carter that much or can they take a chanec on Kost?
I say go for the chance..
WAY TOO EARLY TO TELL...