Proposal: CAR - DAL

[Machinehead]

Joel L'Esperance is a cool ass name

 

[GIN ANTONIC]

Joel L'Esperance is a cool ass name

Should just be Joe for the first name, not Joel. Would be smoother that way. Because of that I vote bust

 

[Lempo]

Should just be Joe for the first name, not Joel. Would be smoother that way. Because of that I vote bust

Counterpoint: I would by the easy listening record by Joelle Sperance.

edit: I meant to mean 'buy', but let's go with this take instead.

 

[TheReelChuckFletcher]

I'm sure that any Faulk sign-and-trade package would have to include Hintz or Carolina would prefer to just own-rental Faulk. Janmark/L'Esperance/Honka isn't a bad offer, though, IF Faulk is strictly a rental. I think a rental package would have to include Faksa, though.

 

[LT]

I'm sure that any Faulk sign-and-trade package would have to include Hintz or Carolina would prefer to just own-rental Faulk.

I'll acknowledge how bad the OP is, but Hintz is arguably as valuable as Faulk right now without any contract considerations. This is equally as bad the other way.

 

[TheReelChuckFletcher]

I'll acknowledge how bad the OP is, but Hintz is arguably as valuable as Faulk right now without any contract considerations. This is equally as bad the other way.

You have to understand the market, though. If Anaheim was offering Kase and conditional picks in a sign-and-trade, an extended Faulk would command at least Roope Hintz in any deal with Dallas. Faulk, at least at this moment, is a better player than Hintz. Even though Hintz had a great playoffs, it's still questionable if he can keep it up over a full year without Zuccarello driving his line.

 

[LT]

Then take the Kase deal. Dallas sure as hell isn't moving Hintz, much less for a rental.

 

[TheReelChuckFletcher]

Then take the Kase deal. Dallas sure as hell isn't moving Hintz, much less for a rental.

Faulk wouldn't be a rental. Faulk wants to be extended before any prospective trade. Faulk is easily worth Hintz in a sign-and-trade swap.

 

[LT]

Faulk wouldn't be a rental. Faulk wants to be extended before any prospective trade. Faulk is easily worth Hintz in a sign-and-trade swap.

That's debatable.

 

[serp]

Faulk wouldn't be a rental. Faulk wants to be extended before any prospective trade. Faulk is easily worth Hintz in a sign-and-trade swap.

But i'm not into extending Faulk before playing a game for the Stars.

Even then Faulk is a luxury and i'm not willing to trade a guy who is looking like he might have a huge breakout year for a luxury.

 

[Canes]

Hintz for Faulk is too far in the other direction in favor of the Canes but it wouldn't be quite a fleecing like the OP.

 

[Roboturner913]

What about Faksa and Honka for Faulk and the rights to Luke Martin?

 

[Kcb12345]

You have to understand the market, though. If Anaheim was offering Kase and conditional picks in a sign-and-trade, an extended Faulk would command at least Roope Hintz in any deal with Dallas. Faulk, at least at this moment, is a better player than Hintz. Even though Hintz had a great playoffs, it's still questionable if he can keep it up over a full year without Zuccarello driving his line.

Zuccarello had very little to do with Hintz's success. Hintz started playing that way while Zucc was injured

 

[Cardiac Jerks]

Joel L'Esperance is a cool ass name

If hockey doesn’t work out he should start a band.

The Joel L’Esperance L’Experience

 

[Murzu]

1st + HonkaHonka for Faulk

 

[spockBokk]

1st + HonkaHonka for Faulk

CAR takes that an runs, doubt they get anywhere close to a 1st tho.