Proposal: CAR - DAL

[LT]

Receive:

Mattias Janmark
Julius Honka
Joel L'Esperance
2020 4th Round Pick

Receive:

Justin Faulk

---

We've discussed this a bit on the Stars' board, what with Faulk being shopped and Honka requesting a trade. My initial thoughts are too much quantity and not enough quality for Faulk, but I have little idea of what Carolina is expecting in return.

Carolina adds a quality bottom 6 forward with a ton of speed, a reclamation project in Honka (if anyone can get something out of him, it's Carolina - plus they'll have both brothers), a pretty decent AHL prospect in L'Esperance, and a pick.

Dallas adds a legitimate top 4 defender to play with Heiskanen or Lindell. With that plus Pavelski, our top 6 forwards and top 4 defenders are up there with any team in the league. Helps us secure a spot in the vicious Central.

Thoughts? Too slanted toward Dallas?

Click to read more...

 

[FreeBobbyFarnham]

I think Janmark/Cogliano + 2nd would make more sense for Carolina. They have no use for Honka and a 4th won't do much for them.

 

[Nikishin Go Boom]

Man another bottom 6 forward and fringe defender is eXaCtLy what Carolina needs

We only 12 capable bottom 6 guys and 6 3rd pairing defenders

 

[Jared Dunn]

Faulk is a #3. This is a wildly underwhelming package

 

[DingDongCharlie]

Why do people even post this garbage?

Spare parts and a 4th? Seriously deluded

 

[Kamiccolo]

I am not seeing why the Canes do this trade tbh

 

[elitepete]

Lol terrible offer

 

[Cardiac Jerks]

No offence but you do a pretty terrible job selling this package

 

[Dr Quincy]

I think Janmark/Cogliano + 2nd would make more sense for Carolina. They have no use for Honka and a 4th won't do much for them.

They have no use for Janmark or Cogliano either.

 

[NetflixandPhil]

I mean 1+1+1+1+1+1+1+1+1+1=10 right?

Sounds like fair value..

 

[Finlandia WOAT]

We'll give you a 4th for Honka solely for the pleasure of f***ing with Montreal.

 

[GIN ANTONIC]

Bad. Please offer 1 thing of decent value and we can get a deal done

 

[EXTRAS]

L'esperance was leading the AHL in goals (as a rookie) before being called up to the nhl last year. He probably has the highest potential of any piece on the Dallas side. Still won't be enough to get faulk. Maybe change the 4th to a late 1st/early 2nd and drop honka.

 

[DFF]

I do not think Carolina is going to get much for Faulk but still Janmark has little value and Honka close to none.

 

[dallas stars 1999]

No for Dallas. Why would we do this? Yes, we agree Faulk is a great defenceman, but contract is coming to an end. Besides we have Johns coming back. If we want him, we'll sign him as ufa when is contract is up. As for Honka a 4th round pick sounds about right.

 

[Canes]

No for Dallas. Why would we do this? Yes, we agree Faulk is a great defenceman, but contract is coming to an end. Besides we have Johns coming back. If we want him, we'll sign him as ufa when is contract is up. As for Honka a 4th round pick sounds about right.

Why would Dallas do this? Because they gain a RH top 4 d-man for a season and have the inside track to re-signing him while giving up basically nothing of worth. Unfortunately for you, our GM isn't that clueless.

 

[serp]

Just out of curiosity anybody reported on how Fauls NTC looks like ? What teams can he be traded to and which not ? He probably will block any trade he can without an extension that includes an NMC since he more than likely doesn't want to be picked by Seattle . Just interested if the Stars would be on the list of teams he can't block .

I'd be interest in Faulk as a rental but not neccesarily long term if the extetion he desires is well underisable for the team. If he can block a trade as a rental i would not be interested

 

[Lempo]

Just out of curiosity anybody reported on how Fauls NTC looks like ? What teams can he be traded to and which not ? He probably will block any trade he can without an extension that includes an NMC since he more than likely doesn't want to be picked by Seattle . Just interested if the Stars would be on the list of teams he can't block .

I'd be interest in Faulk as a rental but not neccesarily long term if the extetion he desires is well underisable for the team. If he can block a trade as a rental i would not be interested

I *think* as the general rule trade clause lists are not made public. It would be bad for the league if it was confirmed that certain teams are on everyone's list as people suspect.

 

[Zapp]

Pretty bad proposal, bunch of depth garbage that CAR doesn't want for a player we wouldn't offer an extension to.

Neither team would do this.

 

[Kcb12345]

No for Dallas. Why would we do this? Yes, we agree Faulk is a great defenceman, but contract is coming to an end. Besides we have Johns coming back. If we want him, we'll sign him as ufa when is contract is up. As for Honka a 4th round pick sounds about right.

Johns isn't coming back. His headaches are the only thing that has come back

 

[dallas stars 1999]

Johns isn't coming back. His headaches are the only thing that has come back

If Johns doesn't come back. He will go on long term, and they will make a trade that makes sense. We don't want to over pay for a defenceman who will be a ufa. Better to wait till July 1.

 

[GIN ANTONIC]

Pretty bad proposal, bunch of depth garbage that CAR doesn't want for a player we wouldn't offer an extension to.

Neither team would do this.

Uhhh Dallas would be silly not to do the proposal. Whether Faulk is a fit for your roster or future or whatever he’s a quality player and you’d be getting him for nothing

 

[LT]

So as I thought, this is definitely way too little going to Carolina.

What's a realistic offer from Dallas for Faulk, then?

 

[Boom Boom Apathy]

As a Canes fan, how can I say no?

Wait, I know how. NO.

 

[Kcb12345]

So as I thought, this is definitely way too little going to Carolina.

What's a realistic offer from Dallas for Faulk, then?

Incoming offers asking for Hintz+ or a 1st+