I think there are some major developmental and drafting issues under MacLellan’s leadership though that can’t be overlooked when undergoing a retool.
I don’t know what Ted would do. MacLellan has had his issues but it’s hard to say he wasn’t the right guy at the time (even if he may not be the guy now), so in that respect Ted deserves some credit.
It's true, it should be considered a crime against humanity that we're struggling to fill our top 6 defenders with all the picks we've put into defense the last half decade, but I also don't think they've been as bad as you'd think. The issue's been twofold.
The first was they've had a Stanley Cup contending team since like 2015 that just didn't have injuries, so there was no time for players to actually graduate and show that they belonged. I can't blame the front office, the coaching staff, or really
anyone for that period where everyone was always healthy and they rarely if ever needed a call up.
The second issue has been there handling of development of players, and this is something I can't entirely blame on the front office. We've let so many guys go, who had some form of success with us, but because they weren't doing it the "right way" in the coaching staffs eye they were shipped out and then proceed to blossom elsewhere. Guys like Burakovsky, Stephenson, and Siegenthaler really bother me looking back on because we unloaded them because the coach/room had issues with them and then someone else was able to turn them into highly productive players. GMBM deserves blame, but I look at it like the Vrana trade. I don't think GMBM wanted to unload that trade for Mantha, but Lavi had issue with him so he had to unload him to get someone he'd use. I think Trotz had similar issues when you look back at his handling of Burakovsky, Vrana, Schmidt, and others.
For example we shouldn't be in 2022 wondering if Lucas Johansen is an NHL level player. He should have probably been given time in 19 or 20 but we trade for Dillon in 19 and then give Chara all the minutes in the world in 2020. The Dillon trade aside, I don't blame GMBM for signing Chara for no money. I do blame a coaching staff that rode him to death instead of trying to cycle him out and keep him fresh and attempt to lean on some younger talent that they had waiting in the pipe.